Skip to main content

Top 8 Best Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oils

UpdatedNovember 13, 2024

Extra virgin olive oil is well-known as one of the most popular types of oils used for cooking. It is incorporated into salads and pastas, among other foods and is known to have various nutritional values. If it comes to olive oil, Italians are extremely proud of their product especially the extra virgin olive oil. Here are some of the recommended Italian extra virgin olive oil that you can easily find in the market.


Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Editor's Choice

Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Elevate your culinary experience with Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil. This exceptional oil boasts a rich, fruity flavor that adds depth to every dish.

See Price on Amazon

Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil is ideal for those who want extra virgin olive oil that is versatile and has a rich, gentle palate.

Pros

  • Made with Nocellara del Belice olives, giving it a rich flavor profile with notes of artichokes and almonds and a peppery finish
  • Filtered extra virgin olive oil, only produced in October, with very low acidity (typically around 0.3%)
  • Can be used for finishing, dipping, and cooking, making it a versatile addition to your kitchen

Cons

  • Pricey compared to other olive oils on the market
  • May not be available in all grocery stores, so you may need to order online
  • Some reviewers have reported issues with the packaging and delivery of the product

In one of our recent cookouts, our team had a chance to try Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil in our recipes, and we were delighted with the intensity of its fruitiness. The Nocellara del Belice olive used in its preparation gives it a perfect finalizing flavor for most recipes, a bread dip, or even cooking.

However, what should be pointed out is that the oil, initially drizzling, is slightly foggy and will clear with time as sediments settle at the bottom. This prevents it from going rancid quickly, and to prolong the shelf life, it comes packed in an opaque dark tin.

In summary, Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil, with its beautiful, distinct taste, can undoubtedly be regarded as an extra virgin olive oil of superb quality. Just be willing and ready to dig a little deeper into your pockets to get better quality.


VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin

VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend purchasing VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin for its award-winning taste and aroma, premium quality, and natural properties.

Pros

  • VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin is a supercharged gourmet extra virgin olive oil that is rich in natural oleocanthal and polyphenol properties.
  • This extra virgin olive oil is high in olive polyphenols and oleocanthal content, as lab reports inside every box confirm.
  • VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin is a premium fresh single-source quality olive oil that is hand-harvested from olive oil trees and cold-pressed within 4 hours to lock in all the powerful phenolic properties.

Cons

  • VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin is an expensive product.
  • Some users may find the taste of VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin too strong for their liking.
  • VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin is a limited edition product, with only 3800 liters produced each year.

VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin is a premium quality extra virgin olive oil that is perfect for natural raw use. The extra virgin olive oil is rich in natural oleocanthal and polyphenol properties, making it a supercharged gourmet extra virgin olive oil that is perfect for drizzling on fresh salads, dipping your favorite bread, or adding to your favorite recipes.

VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin is an award-winning olive oil, with a taste and aroma that is second to none. The extra virgin olive oil is high in olive polyphenols and oleocanthal content, making it a polyphenol-rich olive oil that is perfect for recreating natural chef recipes.

The extra virgin olive oil is a premium fresh single-source quality olive oil that is hand-harvested from olive oil trees and cold-pressed within 4 hours to lock in all the powerful phenolic properties. VIRGEEN Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin is a limited edition product, with only 3800 liters produced each year, making it a premium Italian gift that comes with a protected elegant package, Italian EVOO extra virgin olive oil recipes, instructions for perfect use and conservation.


Mantova Italian Golden Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Mantova Italian Golden Extra Virgin Olive Oil

See Price on Amazon

For an original and worthy Italian extra virgin olive oil, I would suggest Mantova Italian Golden Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

Pros

  • This product is naturally trans fat and cholesterol-free, making it a healthy addition to your diet.
  • The olive oil has a bold, delicious flavor with hints of sweet almond and a smooth profile.
  • The oil is perfect for everyday use in the kitchen and at the table, and makes a great functional gift for the chef in your life.

Cons

  • Some customers have reported receiving damaged cans during shipping.
  • The oil may not be the best choice for dipping due to its low acidity.
  • The product is on the pricier side compared to other olive oils on the market.

We have cooked with this olive oil, for example, in salads, sauces for pasta, and the like, and we have never been disappointed. The taste is awesome and natural and the texture is not grainy, making it convenient to incorporate in any dish.

The price may be slightly higher than that of other products in the market, but we promise our customers that the product we are offering is genuine olive oil that doesn’t compromise quality. Also, it is very suitable to be presented as a gift to someone you know who has a passion for food.

In sum, if you are interested in a superior quality Italian extra virgin olive oil, Mantova Italian Golden Extra Virgin Olive Oil is the most suitable choice.


Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil

See Price on Amazon

If you're looking for an authentic Italian extra virgin olive oil, Frantoia is a great option. We highly recommend it for its quality taste and authentic flavor.

Pros

  • Frantoia has a fruity, sweet flavor with a hint of almond and a spicy aroma that enhances the flavor of any dish.
  • The olives used to make Frantoia are hand-harvested and milled within 24 hours from the harvest, ensuring the freshest taste possible.
  • Frantoia is a multiple award-winning, cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil that adds a delightful finish to meals.

Cons

  • Frantoia is a bit pricey compared to other olive oils on the market.
  • Some users have reported that the price of Frantoia keeps going up.
  • Although Frantoia is advertised as Italian olive oil, it is actually a blend of other countries.

Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil is perfect for seafood dishes, fresh cheeses, vegetable soups, and all types of mixed salads. It is also great as a bread dipping oil or drizzled over pasta, grilled vegetables, and meat dishes. We found that it enhances the flavor of any dish and adds a delightful finish to meals.

Frantoia is obtained from cold-pressed Sicilian olives: Biancolilla, Nocellara del Belice, and Cerasuola - originating in the surrounding hillsides of West-Central Sicily. The oil is continuously extracted, separated by centrifuge, allowed to settle, and then decanted naturally without being filtered. This process ensures that the oil retains its natural flavors and aromas.

Overall, we highly recommend Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil for those who appreciate authentic, high-quality ingredients and want to add a delightful finish to their meals.


Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil Cold Pressed, Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil, Authentic Certified DOP Sicilian EVOO Imported From Italy, 25.4 fl oz (Pack of 1) Primo 25.4 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)

Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil Cold Pressed, Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil, Authentic Certified DOP Sicilian EVOO Imported From Italy, 25.4 fl oz (Pack of 1) Primo 25.4 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)

See price on Amazon

If you want to elevate your dishes with an authentic Sicilian flavor, Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a must-try.

Pros

  • The fruity and spicy notes of green tomato, balsamic herbs, and sweet almond create a harmonious blend of sweet, bitter, and spicy flavors.
  • The early green harvest of the single variety Tonda Iblea olives and cold extraction process ensure a high-quality, polyphenol-rich olive oil.
  • It is versatile and complements a wide range of dishes, from roasted meat and fish to salads and minestrone soup.

Cons

  • It is a bit pricey compared to other olive oils on the market.
  • The strong flavor may not be suitable for those who prefer a milder taste.
  • The bottle design may not be very user-friendly, making it difficult to pour without spilling.

Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a top-quality product that brings out the best flavors in any dish. The intense taste of olive oil can be experienced drizzled on a simple bruschetta, rigorously poured on hot toasted bread, or in a green salad.

This award-winning olive oil is produced in the Chiaramonte Gulfi area of southern Sicily using only the early green harvest of the single variety Tonda Iblea olives and is cold extracted. The olives are cold pressed within six hours of being picked and are organically farmed.

Overall, we highly recommend Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil for those who are looking for an authentic and high-quality Sicilian olive oil that will elevate their dishes to the next level.


AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

See price on Amazon

Want to taste the real Italian extra virgin olive oil? We personally recommend Amazon Fresh Italian EVOO.

Pros

  • Cold extracted for maximum flavor
  • Smooth blend with subtle notes of pepper and herbs
  • Pressed and bottled in Italy for authenticity

Cons

  • Comes in a plastic bottle, which may not be ideal for some consumers
  • Some customers have reported a slightly bitter taste
  • May not be as high-quality as more expensive brands

We have tried AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil for several months now, and the taste and flexibility of the olive oil have been the best. It is suitable for any type of cooking process, including cooking, grilling, and, last but not least, finishing, and that is why it has become our best bet when cooking vegetables or preparing homemade salad dressings.

Another thing that we like about this olive oil is that it has one of the mildest tastes we’ve come across. It has a perfect balance of pepper spiciness and herby flavors but is not at all hot or excessively bitter. And because it is cold extracted, which means that it is roasted and ground without heat, it does not lose its taste and nourishing qualities.

Even better, this AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is cold-pressed and certified Italian, which makes it a genuine product. Not only is it a highly flavorful oil, but it is also very affordable—generally, it costs less than some of the premium extra virgin olive oils.

Although some customers who prefer glass are concerned about the plastic bottle, we have not faced any problem with it. Although some users have complained of a somewhat bitter taste, we have not noticed this.

AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is highly recommended by us to anyone interested in a quality Extra Virgin Olive Oil that is equally as universal as convenient.


Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil

See price on Amazon

Colavita Premium Selection is recommendable if you prefer an all-purpose and Italian genuine extra virgin olive oil.

Pros

  • Made from exclusively European olives, ensuring authentic flavor and quality.
  • Balanced flavor profile, with a perfect blend of fruitiness and spice.
  • Ideal for a variety of culinary uses, including roasting, baking, dressings, and marinades.

Cons

  • Some reviewers have noted that the flavor can be a bit mild for their taste.
  • The large size of the bottle can be difficult to store in a small kitchen.
  • The price per ounce is a bit higher than some other brands.

The producers have employed Colavita Extra Virgin Olive Oil in several dishes, such as salads, roasted vegetables, and marinating. The taste is subtle, with a juicy fruitiness and mild spiciness that is very harmonious and enjoyable. We understand that it is made of olives grown and harvested in Italy, Greece, Spain, and Portugal to give it the real taste.

A word of caution, though, is that the flavor can sometimes be a tad subtle and not as strong as other recognizable names out there. However, it may also be a downside that the bottle is very big and may not fit easily into a small kitchen – check space before ordering one.

All in all, we believe that Colavita Premium Selection Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a great product that can suit all those who want to buy a truly Italian olive oil. It is general-purpose, genuine, and ideal for several cooking purposes.


ROI Ligurian Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

ROI Ligurian Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil

See price on Amazon

It is recommended to buy the ROI Ligurian Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil because it has a fresh and light taste and is extracted naturally.

Pros

  • The olive oil is made from high-quality ingredients, resulting in an outstanding flavor.
  • The low acidity levels and high Polyphenols content (antioxidants) make this olive oil a healthy choice.
  • The taste is delicate and smooth, making it perfect for pairing with fish and salads.

Cons

  • Due to recent weather conditions, there was only a small yield of Taggiasca olives this year, resulting in a blend of Taggiasca and Ogliarola olives.
  • The price point may be higher than other olive oils on the market.
  • The bottle design may not be as aesthetically pleasing as other brands.

The ROI Ligurian Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is made from specially chosen raw materials in Liguria, Italy. The estate is situated in one of the most interesting areas of Italy, where olive trees are cultivated on extremely sloping terrains and cliffs by the sea. Together with the climate and seas, it gives the oil an exquisite taste and an individual smell.

This olive oil is ideal for use in dressings, as a finishing ingredient for cakes, and as an accompaniment for baked vegetables and breads. It is also a great gift idea when bundled with other items from the collection, including the Ligurian Extra Virgin Olive Oil and Basil Pesto Sauce.

In conclusion, the ROI Ligurian Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is a good product to use when you want to use healthy, quality olive oil in your meals.

Buying Guide

Here are the factors that can help one to identify the right Italian extra virgin olive oil to purchase for quality use.

Label Information

The first thing is to read it, but it is better to look for some clues by analyzing the marking. Before buying, check information about the producer, the date when olives were harvested, and the area where they were grown. This information should be written on the body of the bottle, especially for a product that has been tested and is of good quality.

Certification

The second thing is certification which is also a very important thing to consider. The extra virgin olive oils produced in Italy must have a certificate from the Consortium for the Protection of Extra Virgin Olive Oil or the Italian Ministry of Agriculture. These certifications afford the guarantee that the oil is from fresh olives and follows the right production processes.

Taste

One of the important qualities that one has to consider when choosing Italian extra virgin olive oil is its taste. You should find a product that has a fruity taste with a slight bitterness and should end the taste with a hint of pepper. The oil should be smooth to the touch, and the color of the oil should be bright green, indicating a good quality oil.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some trusted brands of extra virgin olive oil?

There are many trusted brands of extra virgin olive oil, but some of the most popular Italian brands include Colavita, Filippo Berio, and Frantoia.

What makes Italian olive oil stand out?

Italian olive oil is known for its high quality and distinct flavor. This is due to the fact that Italy has a long history of olive oil production and the country's climate and soil are ideal for growing olives.

What are the differences between olive oil for cooking and dipping?

Olive oil for cooking is typically less expensive and has a higher smoke point, making it better suited for high-heat cooking methods like frying. Olive oil for dipping is usually more expensive and has a lower smoke point, making it better suited for use as a finishing oil or for drizzling over salads and other dishes.

What are the health benefits of using extra virgin olive oil?

Extra virgin olive oil is rich in antioxidants and healthy fats, which can help reduce the risk of heart disease, lower cholesterol levels, and improve brain function.

What should I look for when buying Italian olive oil?

When buying Italian olive oil, look for labels that indicate the oil is extra virgin and has been produced and bottled in Italy. It's also important to look for a harvest date on the label, as fresher oil is generally of higher quality.

How is the quality of extra virgin olive oil determined?

The quality of extra virgin olive oil is determined by a number of factors, including the type of olive used, the region where the olives were grown, and the production methods used. The oil must also meet certain chemical and sensory standards to be considered extra virgin.

Affiliate Disclosure:
The links provided may earn us a small commission at no additional cost to you if you choose to purchase the recommended product. This support allows our research and editorial team to continue providing high-quality recommendations. As a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising initiative, we are able to earn advertising fees through providing links to products on Amazon.com. Please rest assured that we only recommend high-quality products.