Top 10 Best Foaming Cleansers for Managing Oily Skin
UpdatedOctober 23, 2024
Sebaceous glands are small oil-producing glands in the skin that release sebum, an oily substance that helps keep the skin moisturized and protected. However, these glands can become problematic when they produce too much oil.
Excess oil not only makes your skin look greasy and shiny but also clogs pores, leading to blackheads, whiteheads, and persistent acne. Recent studies have shown that people with oily skin are more prone to severe acne, which can result in long-term scarring and impact self-esteem.
Fortunately, there is a solution that targets these issues directly. Foaming cleansers are specially formulated to tackle excess oil without stripping your skin of essential moisture. In this article, we present the best foaming cleansers for managing oily skin, helping you achieve a clearer, healthier complexion.
Causes and Risk Factors of Oily Skin
Understanding the underlying causes of oily skin is essential for effective management and treatment.
1. Genetic Predisposition
One of the most significant contributors to oily skin is genetics. Individuals with a family history of oily skin are more likely to experience increased sebum (oil) production. An old study published in the British Journal of Dermatology examined sebum production and acne severity in 20 pairs of identical twins and 20 pairs of non-identical twins of the same sex.
The findings revealed that identical twins had almost identical sebum production rates, suggesting that genetics primarily influences sebum production.
2. Hormonal Fluctuations
Hormonal fluctuations, particularly during life stages such as puberty, pregnancy, and menstrual cycles, can greatly affect sebum production. Androgens, which are male hormones found in both genders, encourage the sebaceous glands to produce more oil.
Research has shown that men generally exhibit higher sebum production and larger pore sizes compared to women. This was supported by a study conducted in Korea, which revealed a strong positive correlation between male gender, pore size, and sebum excretion.
In comparison, female hormones are associated with lower oil production. However, during specific phases of the menstrual cycle, such as ovulation, premenopausal women may experience increased sebum production. This is due to hormonal fluctuations that temporarily increase androgen levels, producing more oil.
3. Diet
Diet and lifestyle choices also play a role in the regulation of sebum production. Eating foods with a high glycemic index (GI), like white bread, sugary snacks, and soda, can increase the risk of oily skin and acne.
These foods cause your blood sugar levels to spike, which leads to higher insulin levels in your blood. When insulin levels are high, it lowers the amount of a protein called sex hormone-binding globulin (SHBG). Lower SHBG levels mean more androgens are active in your body, which can increase oil production and contribute to acne.
On the other hand, consuming low-glycemic-index foods, such as whole grains, fruits, and vegetables, helps to keep blood sugar levels stable. This diet can increase SHBG levels and reduce the amount of active androgens. Higher SHBG levels are linked to lower acne risk because they help control oil production.
Studies have shown that a low glycemic load diet not only reduces the size of sebaceous glands (which produce oil) but also decreases inflammation and lowers the expression of certain proteins involved in oil production and inflammation.
4. Humid Climate
High humidity levels can lead to increased sweat and oil production, while heat can cause the sebaceous glands to become more active. A 2015 study investigated how seasonal changes affect biophysical parameters of the skin, including sebum content, in healthy adult Chinese women for a year.
The study found that skin sebum content was higher in the spring and summer compared to autumn and winter. This increase in sebum production was correlated with higher average humidity levels during these seasons. Similarly, skin hydration was greater in spring and summer, which also aligns with higher humidity levels.
5. Stress
Stress has been identified as a factor that can increase sebum production. The release of cortisol, a stress hormone, can stimulate the sebaceous glands. Moreover, another hormone, prolactin, also indirectly influences sebum production. Prolactin increases androgen levels in the body, contributing to oily skin and acne.
In addition to cortisol and prolactin, thyroid hormones and adrenaline also contribute to increased sebum production. These hormones enhance a process known as lipogenesis in sebocytes, which are the cells in sebaceous glands responsible for producing sebum.
Lipogenesis is the process of converting fats into sebum, and when stimulated by thyroid hormones and adrenaline, it leads to an increased amount of sebum being produced. This process explains why chronic stress, which elevates levels of these hormones, can worsen skin conditions by making the skin oilier.
Oily skin is influenced by a complex interplay of genetic, hormonal, dietary, environmental, and psychological factors. Understanding these causes can help develop targeted skincare routines and treatments.
Benefits of Using Foaming Cleansers for Oily Skin
Foaming cleansers are particularly beneficial for individuals with oily skin due to their unique formulations and cleansing properties. These benefits include:
- Effective Oil Removal: Foaming cleansers are designed to create a rich lather that effectively removes excess sebum and oil from the skin's surface.
- Deep Cleansing Properties: The cleansers' foamy nature allows for deeper penetration into the skin, ensuring thorough cleansing.
- Gentle on the Skin: Contrary to some misconceptions, many foaming cleansers are formulated to be gentle on the skin. Advances in skincare technology have led to the development of sulfate-free foaming cleansers that do not strip the skin of its natural oils.
- Reduction in Acne and Breakouts: Oily skin is often prone to acne and breakouts due to excess sebum production and clogged pores. Foaming cleansers help mitigate this issue by providing a thorough cleanse that reduces oiliness and prevents the buildup of acne-causing bacteria.
- Improved Skin Texture: Regular use of foaming cleansers can lead to improved skin texture by maintaining a balanced oil level and preventing the formation of blackheads and whiteheads.
With these benefits in mind, let’s now explore some of the best foaming cleansers available to ensure a clearer and more balanced complexion.
Top 10 Best Foaming Cleansers for Oily Skin
Finding the perfect foaming cleanser for oily skin can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. To help you make an informed choice, we’ve rounded up the best foaming cleansers for oily skin based on these important factors:
- Oil control
- Gentle ingredients
- Brand reputation
- User reviews
- Price and availability
Get ready to ditch the shine and enjoy clearer, healthier skin with our top picks for the best foaming cleansers for oily skin!
Disclaimer:
The details, information, and prices provided in this article are accurate as of the time of writing. These details may vary over time due to product updates, market changes, or other external influences. We recommend verifying any crucial information or prices with relevant sources, as fluctuations and updates are possible.
CeraVe’s Foaming Facial Cleanser is an excellent choice for individuals with oily skin, priced at approximately $18 for a 16-ounce bottle (473 mL). This dermatologist-developed formula effectively removes excess oil, dirt, and makeup while maintaining the skin's natural barrier.
The cleanser features key ingredients such as ceramides, hyaluronic acid, and niacinamide. Ceramides help maintain the skin's protective barrier, hyaluronic acid retains moisture, and niacinamide calms the skin.
One of the standout features of this foaming cleanser is its non-comedogenic, non-irritating, and fragrance-free formula. Users have shared overwhelmingly positive feedback about CeraVe’s foaming cleanser. They praise its ability to thoroughly cleanse without stripping their skin, noting that it leaves their skin feeling clean and moisturized.
Many highlight its gentle yet effective formula, which brightens and tightens their skin. It's particularly appreciated by those with sensitive and oily skin, as it removes impurities without causing irritation or dryness. Users also enjoy the mild, creamy lather that leaves their face feeling smooth and refreshed after each use.
Pros
- Effective oil control
- Has no harsh scent
- Developed with dermatologists
- Calms skin with niacinamide
- Contains ceramides for skin barrier protection
- Includes hyaluronic acid for moisture retention
- Non-comedogenic, no harsh microbeads, and fragrance-free
Cons
- Some users noted that the cleanser does not foam as much as they expected
- Contains parabens (methylparaben and propylparaben) which some users prefer to avoid
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Purifying Foaming Facial Cleanser
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Purifying Foaming Facial Cleanser
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Purifying Foaming Cleanser is a premium daily face wash designed for normal to oily, including sensitive skin. Priced at $17.99 for a 13.52-ounce bottle, this cleanser is formulated with La Roche-Posay's unique prebiotic thermal spring water.
This water is rich in minerals and selenium, offering antioxidant and anti-inflammatory benefits. Known for its soothing and protective properties, it balances the skin's microbiome, reduces irritation, and supports the skin's natural barrier, enhancing overall skin health and comfort.
Additionally, this foaming cleanser’s formula includes niacinamide and ceramide-3. These ingredients work together to effectively cleanse dirt, makeup, and impurities, all while ensuring the skin's natural moisture barrier and pH balance remain undisturbed.
Users have shared positive feedback about La Roche-Posay Toleriane Purifying Foaming Cleanser, highlighting its gentle yet effective cleansing properties. Furthermore, many users have noticed a reduction in breakouts and minimized pores.
Pros
- Gently cleanses without stripping the skin
- Dermatologist-tested and allergy-tested
- Free from parabens, sulfates, and fragrances
- Oil-free/non-comedogenic
Cons
- Some users experienced issues such as broken pumps or cracked bottles upon delivery
- Slightly higher price point compared to other cleansers
Bioré Oil Control Deep Pore Charcoal Facial Cleanser
Bioré Oil Control Deep Pore Charcoal Facial Cleanser
The Bioré Oil Control Deep Pore Charcoal Facial Cleanser is highly recommended for oily skin. It combines powerful ingredients, such as natural charcoal, salicylic acid, glycerin, and sorbitol, to target impurities and excess oil.
This facial cleanser is available for only $8.49 for a 6.77-ounce bottle. Its innovative use of natural charcoal makes it ideal for oily skin types. Natural charcoal is known for its superior oil-absorbing capabilities, which help remove deep-seated dirt and impurities from the pores.
The foaming cleanser is well-liked for its effective cleansing properties. Many have reported that it thoroughly cleanses the skin without causing irritation, making it a reliable option for maintaining clean and clear skin. Users also appreciate the dual benefits of charcoal powder for natural purification and salicylic acid for makeup removal and pore minimization.
Moreover, the cleanser enhances the skin's appearance, making it look bright, vibrant, and smooth. Users appreciate the immediate benefits, often noting that it refreshes and rejuvenates their face. Despite some mentioning a drying effect, the consensus is that it effectively revitalizes the skin and imparts a healthy, clean look.
Pros
- Effectively controls oil and reduces acne
- Provides a deep and thorough cleanse
- Leaves a refreshing and tingly sensation
- Affordable and widely available
- Cruelty-free and vegan-friendly formula
- Dermatologist-tested, oil-free, and suitable for daily use
Cons
- Contains fragrance, which might irritate sensitive skin
- Contains menthol, which may cause a tingling sensation
The EltaMD Foaming Facial Cleanser features Ultra-Fine Self-Foaming Technology, which creates micro-massaging bubbles that help deep clean and remove pollutants, dirt, oil, and makeup from the skin. Plus, this cleanser is enriched with bromelain, a pineapple-derived enzyme that cleanses, reduces inflammation, and removes dead skin cells.
Furthermore, this foaming cleanser features micro-massaging bubbles that infuse more oxygen into the skin's surface. It claims to reduce the recurrence of skin damage by 36% and remove 48% of damaging pollutants.
The cleanser's ability to leave the skin feeling clean and non-greasy has garnered positive feedback, with many recommending it to others for its overall performance and gentle touch. Users mention that it effectively neutralizes oiliness without causing dryness. While this foaming cleanser is highly effective, its higher price of $35 for a 7-ounce bottle may be a drawback for some users.
Pros
- Effective in removing dirt, oil, and makeup
- Reduces inflammation and exfoliates dead skin cells
- Versatile option for various skin concerns
- Gentle and suitable for daily use on all skin types
- Free from parabens, sulfates, and dyes
- Dermatologist-tested, pH-balanced, and non-comedogenic
Cons
- Expensive price point
- Contains fragrance
Cetaphil DermaControl Oil Removing Foam Wash
Cetaphil DermaControl Oil Removing Foam Wash
The Cetaphil DermaControl Oil Removing Foam Wash is another option for individuals with oily skin that offers a thorough yet gentle cleansing experience. Priced around $19 for an 8-ounce bottle, this self-foaming cleanser effectively and gently removes dirt, oil, and makeup.
Its unique formula utilizes Zinc Technology to control surface oil and reduce shine, leaving the skin feeling balanced and refreshed. It also contains other key ingredients like glycerin and dipotassium glycyrrhizate. Glycerin, a natural humectant, aids in retaining skin moisture, while dipotassium glycyrrhizate is widely used in skincare products for its various beneficial properties, including sebum regulation.
Users consistently praise Cetaphil’s foaming cleanser for its effectiveness in managing oily skin. They appreciate how it eliminates excess oil, leaving their face feeling clean without causing irritation or dryness. This combination of thorough cleansing and mildness makes it a favorite among those with oily and sensitive skin.
Pros
- Effectively removes oil, dirt, and makeup
- Controls surface oil and reduces shine
- Hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic
- Free from parabens and synthetic fragrances
Cons
- Users have mixed opinions about the smell
- Contains PEG surfactant, which may cause irritation or allergic reactions in some individuals
- Priced higher than other cleansers
ETUDE SoonJung pH 6.5 Whip Facial Cleanser
ETUDE SoonJung pH 6.5 Whip Facial Cleanser
The gentle cleansing power of the ETUDE SoonJung Whip Facial Cleanser, priced at $14.14 for a 5.07-ounce bottle, is specially formulated for sensitive and oily skin. This cleanser boasts a pH of 6.5, closely matching your skin’s natural level to maintain its balance while effectively removing impurities. The whipped cream texture creates soft, luxurious bubbles that cleanse deeply without removing the skin's natural oils.
Key ingredients like Panthenol (Vitamin B5) and Madecassoside, derived from centella asiatica, work together to soothe and repair the skin. Panthenol helps strengthen the skin barrier and retain moisture, while Madecassoside provides anti-inflammatory benefits, calming irritated skin and promoting healing. Additionally, green tea extract offers antioxidant properties to further soothe and protect the skin.
This hypoallergenic, non-comedogenic cleanser is free from 10 potentially harmful ingredients, including:
- Animal Materials
- Mineral Oil
- Color Additives
- Synthetic Perfume
- Polyacrylamide
- Silicone Oil
- Imidazolidinyl Urea
- Triethanolamine
- PEG Surfactant
- Paraben
Users consistently rate this cleanser highly, appreciating its gentle formulation. Many reviews highlight its soothing properties and the absence of harsh chemicals.
Pros
- pH-balanced formula that matches the skin's natural pH
- Contains soothing ingredients like Panthenol and Madecassoside
- Free from fragrances, parabens, and mineral oils
- Cruelty-free and vegan-friendly formula
- Hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic
- Gentle, whipped cream texture that cleanses without stripping
Cons
- Users have mixed opinions Users have mixed opinions about the scent the smell
- Slightly more expensive compared to some other cleansers
The Round Lab 1025 Dokdo Cleanser, priced at $15 for a 150-mL bottle, is a foamy and creamy cleanser with a low acidic pH (5.0-6.0) that effectively purifies and removes excess sebum without overdrying the skin. Infused with Ulleungdo's deep seawater, this cleanser maintains your skin's moisture balance while clearing away impurities.
This foaming cleanser is packed with beneficial ingredients such as Triple Hyaluronic Acid, Panthenol, Allantoin, and Ceramide NP. The hydrolyzed hyaluronic acid, with its smaller molecule size, penetrates deeply, reducing the appearance of fine lines and ensuring long-lasting hydration.
Users rave about its gentle yet effective formula, mentioning that it leaves their skin feeling clean, refreshed, and balanced. The dense, rich foam also provides gentle exfoliation, making it ideal for sensitive skin as well.
Pros
- Low-acidic formula that balances the level of sebum and moisturization
- Clinically proven cleansing results
- Deeply hydrates and soothes skin
- Gentle exfoliation suitable for sensitive skin
- Cruelty-free and free from common allergens
Cons
- Doesn’t have English instructions on the actual product
- Several users complained about the smell of the cleanser
Paula's Choice Skin Balancing Oil-Reducing Cleanser
Paula's Choice Skin Balancing Oil-Reducing Cleanser
Paula's Choice Skin Balancing Oil-Reducing Cleanser is priced at $22.00 for an 8-ounce bottle and is a perfect solution for individuals with oily skin. This expertly formulated cleanser uses a blend of gentle cleansing ingredients to effectively remove makeup, excess oil, and impurities without over-drying the skin. It features a concentrated cream-to-foam formula that ensures your skin feels soft and balanced post-cleansing.
The key ingredients include glycerin and aloe vera, which ensure the skin's natural moisture balance is maintained and prevent the tight or dry feeling. Additionally, it contains mild surfactants that are effective in dissolving oil and impurities, making it particularly suitable for oily and combination skin types.
This foaming cleanser’s non-irritating formula has been praised by users for keeping the skin clear without causing breakouts. This has been the go-to option for many looking to manage their oily skin effectively.
Pros
- Effectively removes excess oil and impurities
- Maintains skin's natural moisture balance
- Non-irritating formula suitable for sensitive skin
- Cream-to-foam texture for a refreshing cleanse
- Positive user feedback for managing oily skin
Cons
- Several users reported it stung their eyes
- The price might be on the higher side for some users
Clean & Clear Essentials Sensitive Skin Foaming Cleanser
Clean & Clear Essentials Sensitive Skin Foaming Cleanser
The Clean & Clear Essentials Sensitive Skin Foaming Facial Cleanser is a gentle solution to keeping your skin healthy and fresh. This affordable foaming cleanser, priced at around $8 for an 8-oz bottle, features surfactants derived from coconut oil.
Users have consistently praised Clean & Clear’s foaming cleanser for its oil-free formulation that cleanses without causing dryness or irritation. They note that it leaves their skin feeling refreshed and grease-free. Many users highlight the product's gentle nature, making it ideal for sensitive skin, and report that it helps keep their skin clear and nearly acne-free.
The cleanser is also recognized for its affordability and value, with users stating that it outperforms more expensive alternatives. However, there are mixed opinions on its foaming capability. While some users enjoy its rich lather, others feel it doesn't foam as expected.
Pros
- Affordable price
- Effective oil control
- Gentle on sensitive skin
- Removes dirt, oil, and makeup efficiently
- Oil-free and non-comedogenic formula
- Free from parabens, phthalates, sulfates, oils, and dyes
Cons
- Some users feel it doesn't foam as expected
The COSRX Calming Foam Cleanser is a must-have for individuals with oily skin. Priced at $15 for a 5.07 fl. oz (150ml) bottle, this cleanser tackles excess oil and acne, providing a thorough yet gentle cleanse that leaves your skin feeling fresh and balanced.
Key ingredients like salicylic acid and the Centella AC-RX complex work synergistically to dissolve dead skin cells, unclog pores, and soothe irritated skin. Salicylic Acid, renowned for its acne-fighting properties, helps reduce breakouts by penetrating deep into the pores. The Centella AC-RX Complex, which includes Madecassic acid, Asiaticoside, and Asiatic acid, aids in healing and revitalizing the skin, making it ideal for sensitive and acne-prone skin types.
Customers rave about the foaming cleanser's ability to leave their skin feeling clean and refreshed without over-drying or irritating sensitive skin. Many users love the rich lather it produces, which ensures a thorough cleanse without leaving any residue.
Pros
- Effectively removes impurities and excess oil
- Contains acne-fighting ingredients
- Soothes and heals irritated skin
- Gentle foam texture
- Suitable for sensitive skin
Cons
- Contains potential allergens like Lavandula Hybrida Oil
- Contains PEG surfactant, which may cause irritation or allergic reactions in some individuals
Takeaway
Choosing the best foaming cleanser can greatly improve your skin. Among the top options available, three stand out for their unique formulations and user satisfaction. CeraVe’s Foaming Facial Cleanser is ideal for oily and sensitive skin, offering a dermatologist-developed formula with ceramides, hyaluronic acid, and niacinamide.
La Roche-Posay Toleriane Purifying Foaming Facial Cleanser features prebiotic thermal spring water, niacinamide, and ceramide-3. This premium cleanser is highly recommended for normal to oily, including sensitive skin, due to its gentle yet effective cleansing properties and ability to maintain the skin's natural moisture barrier.
Lastly, Bioré Oil Control Deep Pore Charcoal Facial Cleanser combines natural charcoal and salicylic acid to target impurities and excess oil. It is particularly effective for oily skin, providing a deep cleanse and a refreshing sensation.
These foaming cleansers offer unique benefits, catering to different skin concerns and preferences. Try one of these highly recommended foaming cleansers today and experience the difference for yourself.
📰 Helpful Articles:
If you found this article helpful, you might also be interested in the following:
FAQs on Foaming Cleansers
Can foaming cleansers cause dryness or irritation?
While foaming cleansers are designed to remove excess oil, some can be too harsh and strip the skin's natural moisture, resulting in dryness or irritation. Look for cleansers that contain gentle surfactants and moisturizing ingredients to prevent this issue. Examples of gentle surfactants include Cocamidopropyl Betaine, Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate, Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Alkyl Sarcosinates, and Alkyl Sulfosuccinates.
Are foaming cleansers suitable for sensitive, oily skin?
Yes, there are foaming cleansers formulated specifically for sensitive, oily skin. These products typically contain soothing ingredients like aloe vera or chamomile to minimize irritation while effectively cleansing the skin.
Is it necessary to follow up with a moisturizer after using a foaming cleanser?
Yes, following up with a moisturizer is essential, even if you have oily skin. Using a lightweight, non-comedogenic moisturizer helps to maintain the skin's hydration balance without adding excess oil. A good moisturizer typically contains occlusive agents, humectants, and emollients.
Can I use a foaming cleanser with other active ingredients like retinoids or vitamin C?
Yes, foaming cleansers can be used in conjunction with other active ingredients like retinoids or vitamin C, but it is important to introduce these products gradually and monitor your skin's response. Retinoids and vitamin C are powerful skincare ingredients that can offer numerous benefits, such as improved skin texture, reduction of fine lines, and brightening of the complexion. However, both can also cause irritation, especially if used excessively or if your skin is not accustomed to them.
Can foaming cleansers remove makeup effectively?
Many foaming cleansers are formulated to remove makeup, dirt, and excess oil. However, for heavy or waterproof makeup, you might need a dedicated makeup remover or a double cleansing routine for thorough cleansing.
References
Walton S, Wyatt EH, Cunliffe WJ. (1988). Genetic control of sebum excretion and acne--a twin study. Br J Dermatol. 1988 Mar;118(3):393-6. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2133.1988.tb02433.x
Roh M, Han M, Kim D, Chung K. (2006). Sebum output as a factor contributing to the size of facial pores. Br J Dermatol. 2006 Nov;155(5):890-4. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2133.2006.07465.x
Elsaie, M. (2016). Hormonal treatment of acne vulgaris: an update. Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology, Volume 9, 241–248. https://doi.org/10.2147/ccid.s114830
Endly, D. C., & Miller, R. A. (2017). Oily Skin: A review of Treatment Options. PubMed Central (PMC). Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5605215/
Rahrovan, S., Fanian, F., Mehryan, P., Humbert, P., & Firooz, A. (2018). Male versus female skin: What dermatologists and cosmeticians should know. International Journal of Women’s Dermatology, 4(3), 122–130. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijwd.2018.03.002
Romańska-Gocka, K., Woźniak, M., Kaczmarek-Skamira, E., & Zegarska, B. (2016). The possible role of diet in the pathogenesis of adult female acne. Postępy Dermatologii I Alergologii, 6, 416–420. https://doi.org/10.5114/ada.2016.63880
Wan MJ, Su XY, Zheng Y, Gong ZJ, Yi JL, Zhao Y, Guan XM, Lai W. (2014). Seasonal variability in the biophysical properties of forehead skin in women in Guangzhou City, China. Int J Dermatol. 2015 Nov;54(11):1319-24. https://doi.org/10.1111/ijd.12741
Borzyszkowska, D., Borzyszkowska, D., Borzyszkowska, D., Borzyszkowska, D., Borzyszkowska, D., Borzyszkowska, D., Borzyszkowska, D., & Borzyszkowska, D. (2022). Evaluation of Hormonal Factors in Acne Vulgaris and the Course of Acne Vulgaris Treatment with Contraceptive-Based Therapies in Young Adult Women. Cells, 11(24), 4078. https://doi.org/10.3390/cells11244078
Pappas, A., Johnsen, S., Liu, J., & Eisinger, M. (2009). Sebum analysis of individuals with and without acne. Dermato-endocrinology, 1(3), 157–161. https://doi.org/10.4161/derm.1.3.8473
Dabash, D., Salahat, H., Awawdeh, S., Hamadani, F., Khraim, H., Koni, A. A., & Zyoud, S. H. (2024). Prevalence of acne and its impact on quality of life and practices regarding self-treatment among medical students. Scientific Reports, 14(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-55094-6