Skip to main content
Read about

What is the cost of treating non-specific eye pain?

Non-specific eye pain can be a concerning and uncomfortable experience, leaving many wondering about the best course of action for diagnosis and treatment. This article aims to provide a comprehensive guide to understanding the costs associated with treating non-specific eye pain. We'll explore various severity levels, diagnostic approaches, and treatment options, along with their respective costs and time investments. Whether you're dealing with mild discomfort or more severe symptoms, you'll learn about the potential expenses involved in everything from self-assessment to emergency care. We'll also discuss strategies for optimizing your treatment plan based on cost-effectiveness and efficiency. By the end of this article, you'll be equipped with the knowledge to make informed decisions about managing non-specific eye pain while considering both your health and your wallet.
Tooltip Icon.
Written by Andrew Le, MD.
Medically reviewed by
Last updated September 13, 2024

Try our free symptom checker

Get a thorough self-assessment before your visit to the doctor.

Severity Levels of Non-Specific Eye Pain

Non-specific eye pain can vary in intensity and impact on daily life. Understanding the different severity levels can help patients and healthcare providers determine the most appropriate course of action for diagnosis and treatment.

Mild

Mild non-specific eye pain is often characterized by minor discomfort that doesn't significantly interfere with daily activities.

  • Symptoms: Slight irritation, occasional burning sensation, mild redness
  • Risk factors: Extended screen time, dry environments, allergies
  • Diagnosis: Self-assessment or virtual doctor consultation is usually sufficient
  • Imaging/Labs: Generally not required
  • Treatments: Over-the-counter lubricating eye drops, warm compresses, and reducing eye strain are typically effective

Moderate

Moderate non-specific eye pain is more noticeable and may start to impact daily functioning.

  • Symptoms: Persistent discomfort, increased sensitivity to light, moderate redness, and occasional blurred vision
  • Risk factors: Contact lens use, recent eye strain, minor eye injuries
  • Diagnosis: In-person doctor visit recommended for proper evaluation
  • Imaging/Labs: Basic eye exam may be necessary
  • Treatments: Prescription eye drops (e.g., antibiotic or steroid), oral pain medications, and lifestyle modifications

Severe

Severe non-specific eye pain is intense and significantly interferes with daily activities, potentially indicating a more serious underlying condition.

  • Symptoms: Intense pain, severe redness, significant vision changes, eye discharge
  • Risk factors: Recent eye surgery, immune system disorders, severe eye injuries
  • Diagnosis: Emergency room visit or immediate ophthalmologist consultation is crucial
  • Imaging/Labs: Comprehensive eye exam and possibly additional specialized tests
  • Treatments: Prescription medications (both topical and oral), possible procedures, and close medical monitoring

Summary Table: Severity Levels

SeverityCharacteristicsDiagnosisLabs/ImagingTreatment
MildSlight irritation, occasional burningSelf-assessment or virtual consultationGenerally not requiredOTC drops, warm compresses
ModeratePersistent discomfort, light sensitivityIn-person doctor visitBasic eye examPrescription drops, oral pain meds
SevereIntense pain, vision changes, dischargeER or immediate ophthalmologistComprehensive exam, specialized testsPrescription meds, possible procedures

Getting a Diagnosis

When seeking a diagnosis for non-specific eye pain, several options are available, ranging from self-assessment to emergency care. The choice depends on the severity of symptoms and personal circumstances. Let's explore each option in detail:

Self-assessment

Self-assessment is suitable for mild cases of non-specific eye pain. While it doesn't incur direct costs, it's important to note that this method carries risks if symptoms are more severe than perceived.

  • Cost: Free
  • Time: 10-15 minutes

Virtual doctor consultation

Virtual consultations have become increasingly popular, offering convenience and often lower costs compared to in-person visits.

  1. Teladoc
    • General Medical Visits:
      • With insurance: $0 per visit (based on your benefits)
      • Without insurance: $89 per visit
    • Therapy Sessions:
      • With insurance: $0-$99 per session
      • Without insurance: $99 per session
    • Psychiatry Visits:
      • With insurance: $0-$299 for the first visit, $0-$129 for subsequent visits
      • Without insurance: $299 for the first visit, $119 for subsequent visits
  2. MDLive
    • Urgent Care: $85 (without insurance)
    • Dermatology: $95 (without insurance)
    • Therapy: $108 per session (without insurance)
    • Psychiatry:
      • Initial Consultation: $284 (without insurance)
      • Follow-up Appointments: $108 (without insurance)
    • With insurance: Costs may be lower or even $0, depending on your plan
  3. OptimalMD
    • Cost: Free with OptimalMD membership ($47/month for the entire family)
    • Time: Same-day availability, typically 15-30 minutes

Virtual consultations offer quick and convenient access to medical professionals, making them suitable for mild to moderate cases of non-specific eye pain.

In-person doctor visit

For moderate cases or when a physical examination is necessary, an in-person visit to a primary care physician or an optometrist may be recommended.

  1. Primary Care Physician (PCP)
    • Basic Visit: $150 to $300 (average $171) without insurance
    • Level 1 Health Concern: Around $68
    • Level 5 Health Concern: Approximately $234
    • With insurance: Copay typically $20-$50
  2. Optometrist
    • Initial Patient Exam: $171-$200 on average
      • Some retailers offer lower prices:
      • Walmart Vision Center: $75 and up
      • Target Optical: $70-$100
      • Sam's Club: $45 and up
    • Established Patient Exam: $100-$150 on average
    • Refractive Vision Tests: $46-$60 on average
    • With insurance: Copay or possibly $0-$100 depending on plan
  3. OptimalMD In-Network Providers
    • Cost: Heavily discounted with OptimalMD membership
    • Time: Varies, typically 30-60 minutes, may require appointment scheduling

In-person visits allow for a more thorough examination and are appropriate for moderate cases of non-specific eye pain or when virtual consultations are insufficient.

Emergency room visit

For severe cases or when immediate care is necessary, an emergency room visit may be required.

  • Insured Patients:
    • Average cost: $1,082 (2019 data)
    • Out-of-pocket cost: $646 (2022 data)
  • Uninsured Patients:
    • Average cost: $2,600
  • Additional Costs:
    • Ambulance services: $25 to $1,200, depending on insurance and type of plan
    • High-deductible insurance plans: Deductibles can range from $1,669 for individuals to $5,000 for families

Emergency room visits are typically the most expensive option but are necessary for severe or potentially sight-threatening conditions.

Summary Table: Assessment Options

ModalityAppropriate Severity Level(s)Price Without InsurancePrice With InsuranceEfficiency
Self-assessmentMildFreeFreeHigh
Virtual consultation (Teladoc)Mild to Moderate$89$0-$99High
Virtual consultation (MDLive)Mild to Moderate$85$0-$85High
Virtual consultation (OptimalMD)Mild to ModerateFree with membershipFree with membershipHigh
PCP visitMild to Moderate$150-$300Copay ($20-$50)Medium

Note: Prices are estimates and may vary based on location, specific services provided, and individual insurance plans. OptimalMD membership is $47/month for the entire family.

Imaging and Laboratory Tests

When it comes to diagnosing and monitoring non-specific eye pain, various imaging and laboratory tests may be necessary. The type of test required often depends on the severity of the symptoms and the initial assessment by a healthcare provider. Let's explore the common tests, their costs, and time considerations.

Basic Eye Exam

A basic eye exam is often the first step in diagnosing eye-related issues, including non-specific eye pain. This exam typically includes visual acuity tests, pupil reactions, and a general examination of the eye's external structures.

  • LensCrafters: $73 - $79 without insurance
  • Walmart Vision Center: $65 - $100 without insurance
  • OptimalMD: Free with OptimalMD membership

With vision insurance, these exams may be covered entirely or require a small copay, typically ranging from $10 to $40.

Time: 30-60 minutes

Comprehensive Eye Exam

A comprehensive eye exam is more thorough than a basic exam and may be necessary for moderate to severe cases of non-specific eye pain. This exam includes all elements of a basic exam plus additional tests such as refraction, eye pressure measurement, and a detailed examination of the retina and optic nerve.

  • Private Ophthalmologist: $110 - $200 without insurance
  • America's Best: $69 without insurance
  • OptimalMD: Free with OptimalMD membership

With vision insurance, comprehensive exams may be fully covered or require a copay of $20 to $50.

Time: 60-90 minutes

Additional Tests

For more complex cases, additional tests may be necessary. Two common advanced tests are Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT) and Visual Field Test.

Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT)

OCT provides detailed images of the retina and optic nerve, which can be crucial in diagnosing certain eye conditions.

  • RetinaScan: $39 - $60 without insurance
  • EyeTech Diagnostics: $99 without insurance
  • OptimalMD: Heavily discounted with OptimalMD membership

With insurance, OCT scans may be covered partially or fully, depending on the plan and medical necessity.

Time: 5-10 minutes

Visual Field Test

A visual field test assesses peripheral vision and can help detect certain eye conditions that might be causing pain.

  • VisionWorks: Included in comprehensive exam (starting at $75 without insurance)
  • EyeCare Center: $84 - $124 without insurance
  • OptimalMD: Heavily discounted with OptimalMD membership

Insurance coverage for visual field tests varies depending on the plan and medical necessity. With insurance, patients might pay a copay of $20 to $50.

Time: 15-30 minutes

Summary Table: Diagnostics

ModalityAppropriate Severity Level(s)Price Without InsurancePrice With InsuranceEfficiency (Time)
Basic Eye ExamMild to Moderate$65 - $100$0 - $40 copay30-60 minutes
Comprehensive Eye ExamModerate to Severe$69 - $200$0 - $50 copay60-90 minutes
OCT ScanModerate to Severe$39 - $99Varies, often partially covered5-10 minutes
Visual Field TestModerate to Severe$84 - $124$20 - $50 copay15-30 minutes

Note: All tests are either free or heavily discounted with OptimalMD membership at $47/month for the entire family.

Prescription Medications

Prescription medications play a crucial role in treating non-specific eye pain, especially for moderate to severe cases. The choice of medication depends on the underlying cause and severity of the condition. Here are some common prescription medications used for non-specific eye pain:

Antibiotic eye drops

Antibiotic eye drops are prescribed when there's a suspected bacterial infection causing eye pain. One common example is Tobramycin eye drops.

  • Brand name options: Tobrex, Tobradex
  • Generic option: Tobramycin

Pricing:

  • Cash price: The average retail price for 5 milliliters of generic Tobramycin is $35.00.
  • With insurance: Copays vary, typically ranging from $10 to $30.
  • With discount card: As low as $7.56 at participating pharmacies.
  • OptimalMD: Free with OptimalMD membership

Specific pharmacy prices (for 5 ml):

  • Walgreens: $11.51
  • CVS Pharmacy: $28.43
  • Rite Aid Pharmacy: $16.38
  • Walmart Pharmacy: $22.25
  • Kroger Pharmacy: $19.96

Duration: Typically prescribed for 7-10 days

Steroid eye drops

Steroid eye drops are used to reduce inflammation in the eye. A common example is Prednisolone eye drops.

  • Brand name options: Pred Forte, Omnipred
  • Generic option: Prednisolone acetate

Pricing:

  • Cash price: The average retail price for 5 milliliters of generic Prednisolone acetate 1% is $40.00.
  • With insurance: Copays typically range from $30 to $60.
  • With discount card: As low as $22.93 with a BuzzRx coupon.
  • Amazon Pharmacy: $10.00 for Prednisolone Acetate, 1% Ophthalmic Suspension (5 ml).
  • OptimalMD: Free with OptimalMD membership

Duration: Variable, as directed by the doctor. Typically used for 1-2 weeks, tapering off gradually.

Oral pain medications

For more severe pain or when eye drops are insufficient, oral pain medications may be prescribed. Ibuprofen is a common choice.

  • Brand name options: Advil, Motrin
  • Generic option: Ibuprofen

Pricing (for 800 mg tablets, 30-count):

  • Cash price: Average retail price is $33.08.
  • With insurance: Copays typically range from $5 to $15.
  • With discount card: As low as $2.76 with a SingleCare prescription drug discount card.
  • OptimalMD: Free with OptimalMD membership

Duration: As needed or as directed by the doctor, typically for a few days to a week.

It's important to note that while OptimalMD offers significant savings on prescription medications, the choice of treatment should always be based on medical necessity as determined by a healthcare professional. The OptimalMD membership at $47 per month for the entire family can provide substantial cost savings for those requiring frequent medical care or medications.

Summary Table: Prescription Medications

MedicationSeverity LevelPrice Without InsurancePrice With InsuranceEfficiency
Tobramycin eye drops (5ml)Moderate$35.00 (avg retail)$10-$30 copayHigh for bacterial infections, 7-10 days treatment
Prednisolone eye drops (5ml)Moderate to Severe$40.00 (avg retail)$30-$60 copayHigh for inflammation, 1-2 weeks treatment
Ibuprofen (800mg, 30 count)Mild to Severe$33.08 (avg retail)$5-$15 copayModerate for pain relief, as needed
Any covered medication with OptimalMDAll levelsFree with $47/month family membershipN/AVaries by medication

Note: Prices may vary depending on location, pharmacy, and specific insurance plans. The OptimalMD option provides significant cost savings for families requiring frequent medical care or medications.

Over-the-Counter Treatments

Over-the-counter (OTC) treatments can be an effective and affordable option for managing non-specific eye pain, particularly for mild to moderate cases. These treatments are readily accessible and can often provide quick relief. Let's explore the various OTC options, their costs, and effectiveness.

Lubricating Eye Drops

Lubricating eye drops, also known as artificial tears, are a common first-line treatment for non-specific eye pain. They help to moisturize the eye and can alleviate discomfort caused by dryness or irritation.

Let's look at some popular brands and their costs:

  • Systane Ultra Lubricant Eye Drops
    • National average price: $13.99 for a 10mL bottle
    • Amazon: $11.97 (with coupon) for a twin pack (10mL each)
    • Walgreens: $14.99 for 0.33 fl oz (approximately 10mL)
    • Target: $11.99 for 10mL
  • Refresh Tears Lubricant Eye Drops
    • National average price: $14.27 for a 15mL bottle
    • Target: $14.69 for a 2-count, 15mL each
    • Walgreens: $14.99 for 15mL
    • Amazon: $13.14 for a 2-count, 15mL each

It's worth noting that generic versions of these lubricating eye drops are often available at a lower cost. For example, many pharmacies offer store-brand artificial tears that can be 30-50% cheaper than brand-name options.

Duration: Use as needed or as directed by the package instructions. A single bottle typically lasts 1-2 months with regular use.

Warm Compresses

Warm compresses are a cost-effective home remedy that can help alleviate eye discomfort and promote better eye health. While you can make a warm compress at home using a clean washcloth and warm water, there are also commercial options available:

  • Bruder Moist Heat Eye Compress
    • National average price: $40.00
    • Amazon: $32.99
    • Walgreens: $39.99
  • The Body Source Lavender Eye Pillow
    • National average price: $14.99
    • Amazon: $14.99

Duration: Apply the warm compress for 10-15 minutes, several times daily as needed. These products are reusable and can last for several months to a year with proper care.

Non-prescription Pain Relievers

Over-the-counter pain relievers can help manage eye pain and associated headaches. Common options include:

  • Tylenol Extra Strength (Acetaminophen)
    • National average price: $19.97 for 100 caplets
    • Walgreens: $22.99 for 225 caplets ($0.10 per caplet)
    • Amazon: $10.84 for 100 caplets ($0.11 per caplet)
  • Advil (Ibuprofen)
    • National average price: $10.99 for 100 tablets
    • Walgreens: $10.99 for 100 tablets ($0.11 per tablet)
    • Amazon: $9.97 for 100 tablets ($0.10 per tablet)

Generic versions of these medications are often available at a significantly lower cost, sometimes up to 50% less than the brand-name versions.

Duration: Follow the package instructions for dosage and duration. Typically, these medications can be taken as needed for pain relief.

Summary Table: OTCs

ModalitySeverity LevelPrice (Brand)Price (Generic)Efficiency
Lubricating Eye DropsMild to Moderate$13-$15$7-$10High
Warm CompressesMild to Moderate$15-$40$5-$10 (DIY)Moderate
Non-prescription Pain RelieversMild to Severe$11-$23 per 100$5-$10 per 100Moderate

Note: Prices are approximate and may vary based on location, retailer, and current promotions. Generic prices are estimates based on typical market differences between brand-name and generic products. Efficiency is based on general effectiveness for non-specific eye pain relief.

Procedures (if applicable)

When non-specific eye pain is caused by certain conditions, medical procedures may be necessary. Here, we'll discuss two common procedures: foreign body removal and punctal plug insertion.

Removal of foreign body

Foreign body removal is a procedure performed when an object, such as a small piece of metal or wood, becomes lodged in the eye. This procedure is typically necessary for moderate to severe cases of eye pain caused by foreign objects.

Cost:

  • National Average: $108 to $367 (cash price)
  • MinuteClinic: $99 to $139 (cash price)

Insurance and Payment Options:

  • With insurance: Copay or coinsurance typically applies. Check with your insurance provider for specific coverage details.
  • Discount cards: May offer 10-20% off the cash price at participating providers.

Time: 15-30 minutes

Providers:

  • MinuteClinic (various locations across the US)
  • Local ophthalmologists or optometrists
  • Urgent care centers (e.g., CityMD, although specific pricing is not available)

Punctal plug insertion

Punctal plug insertion is a procedure used to treat dry eye syndrome, which can sometimes cause non-specific eye pain. This procedure is typically recommended for moderate cases that haven't responded to other treatments.

Cost:

  • National Average:
    • Medicare reimbursement: $194 (office setting), $125 (facility setting)
    • Plug cost: $30 to $150 (temporary plugs), $75 to $150 (permanent plugs)

Insurance and Payment Options:

  • With insurance: Most insurance plans cover the procedure and the cost of the plugs. Patient responsibility may include copay or coinsurance.
  • Cash price: May vary significantly depending on the provider and location. Contact local ophthalmologists for specific pricing.

Time: 10-15 minutes per eye

Providers:

  • Local ophthalmologists
  • Some optometrists (check for those specializing in dry eye treatment)

It's important to note that the costs provided are estimates and can vary based on factors such as geographical location, specific provider, and individual patient circumstances. Always consult with your healthcare provider and insurance company for the most accurate cost information for your situation.

Summary Table: Procedures

ProcedureSeverity LevelPrice Without InsurancePrice With InsuranceEfficiency
Foreign Body RemovalModerate to Severe$99 - $367Copay/Coinsurance15-30 minutes
Punctal Plug InsertionModerate$224 - $494*Typically Covered10-15 minutes per eye

*Price includes average procedure cost plus cost of plugs

Optimizing for Cost

When seeking treatment for non-specific eye pain, there are several strategies to minimize costs while still receiving appropriate care. Here's a breakdown of cost-effective approaches for each severity level:

Mild Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Self-assessment using reputable online resources
  • Over-the-counter lubricating eye drops (generic brands)
  • Warm compresses using items already available at home
  • Generic non-prescription pain relievers if needed

Moderate Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Virtual doctor consultation instead of in-person visit when possible
  • Generic prescription medications when available
  • Comparison shopping for basic eye exams at different providers
  • Utilizing telemedicine follow-ups to reduce the number of in-person visits

Severe Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Seeking care at an urgent care center instead of the emergency room when appropriate
  • Asking for generic alternatives to brand-name medications
  • Inquiring about payment plans or financial assistance programs for necessary procedures
  • Exploring community health clinics or teaching hospitals for potentially lower-cost care

General Cost-Saving Tips

  • Check if your insurance offers free or low-cost telemedicine consultations
  • Look for manufacturer coupons or patient assistance programs for prescription medications
  • Consider opening a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Flexible Spending Account (FSA) to use pre-tax dollars for medical expenses
  • Don't skip follow-up appointments, as this can lead to more costly complications in the long run

By implementing these cost-optimizing strategies, patients can often reduce their overall expenses while still receiving appropriate care for non-specific eye pain. However, it's crucial to balance cost-saving measures with the need for prompt and effective treatment, especially in cases of severe eye pain or vision changes.

Optimizing for Efficiency

When time is of the essence, optimizing the treatment plan for non-specific eye pain can help patients find relief quickly. Here are strategies for maximizing efficiency at each severity level:

Mild Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Utilize virtual doctor consultations for quick assessments
  • Opt for over-the-counter treatments that can be started immediately
  • Use home remedies like warm compresses while waiting for professional advice

Moderate Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Schedule same-day in-person doctor visits when possible
  • Choose pharmacies that offer quick prescription filling services
  • Select medications with convenient dosing schedules to minimize disruption to daily life

Severe Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Go directly to the emergency room or an ophthalmologist for immediate care
  • Request expedited imaging and lab tests when medically necessary
  • Consider combination therapies that address multiple symptoms simultaneously

General Efficiency Tips

  • Keep a home eye care kit stocked with common OTC treatments
  • Maintain up-to-date prescriptions for recurring eye issues
  • Establish a relationship with an eye care professional for faster future appointments

By prioritizing efficiency in the treatment plan, patients can minimize discomfort and potential complications associated with non-specific eye pain. However, it's crucial to balance speed with thorough and appropriate care to ensure the best possible outcomes.

Balancing Cost and Efficiency

When treating non-specific eye pain, finding the right balance between cost-effectiveness and efficiency is crucial. Here's a breakdown of balanced approaches for each severity level:

Mild Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Start with self-assessment and over-the-counter treatments
  • If symptoms persist for more than 2-3 days, consider a virtual doctor consultation
  • Use generic lubricating eye drops and warm compresses as first-line treatments
  • Time to resolution: 3-7 days
  • Estimated total cost: $[placeholder]

Moderate Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Begin with a virtual doctor consultation for initial assessment
  • If recommended, schedule an in-person visit with an optometrist or general practitioner
  • Opt for generic prescription medications when possible
  • Consider a basic eye exam if symptoms don't improve within a week
  • Time to resolution: 1-2 weeks
  • Estimated total cost: $[placeholder]

Severe Non-Specific Eye Pain

  • Seek immediate in-person medical attention, either at an urgent care center or emergency room
  • Follow up with an ophthalmologist within 24-48 hours
  • Undergo necessary imaging and lab tests as recommended
  • Use a combination of prescription medications and at-home treatments
  • Time to resolution: 2-4 weeks
  • Estimated total cost: $[placeholder]

By following these balanced approaches, patients can receive appropriate care while minimizing unnecessary expenses and time investments. Remember that early intervention and adherence to treatment plans can often prevent more costly and time-consuming complications in the long run.

Conclusion

Non-specific eye pain can vary greatly in severity and cause, making proper diagnosis and treatment crucial for effective management. This article has explored the various costs associated with treating non-specific eye pain, from mild cases that may be managed at home to severe cases requiring immediate medical attention.

Key takeaways include:

  1. The importance of accurate diagnosis, whether through self-assessment, virtual consultation, or in-person medical visits, to determine the appropriate level of care needed.
  2. Understanding the potential costs involved in imaging and laboratory tests, which can range from basic eye exams to more comprehensive evaluations.
  3. The variety of treatment options available, including over-the-counter remedies, prescription medications (both brand-name and generic), and potential procedures for more severe cases.
  4. Strategies for optimizing treatment plans based on cost, efficiency, or a balance of both, depending on individual circumstances and severity of symptoms.
  5. The potential for significant cost savings by considering generic medication options and exploring telemedicine for initial consultations when appropriate.

Ultimately, while cost is an important factor in healthcare decisions, it should not come at the expense of proper treatment. By understanding the various options available and their associated costs, patients can make informed decisions about their eye care in consultation with healthcare professionals. Remember that early intervention and appropriate treatment can often prevent more costly complications down the line, making it essential to address non-specific eye pain promptly and effectively.

Share your story
Once your story receives approval from our editors, it will exist on Buoy as a helpful resource for others who may experience something similar.
The stories shared below are not written by Buoy employees. Buoy does not endorse any of the information in these stories. Whenever you have questions or concerns about a medical condition, you should always contact your doctor or a healthcare provider.
Jeff brings to Buoy over 20 years of clinical experience as a physician assistant in urgent care and internal medicine. He also has extensive experience in healthcare administration, most recently as developer and director of an urgent care center. While completing his doctorate in Health Sciences at A.T. Still University, Jeff studied population health, healthcare systems, and evidence-based medi...
Read full bio

Was this article helpful?

Tooltip Icon.