Skip to main content

Top 9 Best Pillow Top Mattress Toppers

UpdatedMay 29, 2024

A good night's sleep is essential, and the right mattress topper can make all the difference. One popular type of mattress topper is the pillow top, which provides an extra layer of cushioning and support. Pillow top mattress toppers come in a variety of materials, including memory foam, down alternative, and feather.

When choosing a pillow top mattress topper, it's important to consider the type of material that will work best for your sleeping habits. Memory foam is a popular choice for those who need extra support and pressure relief, while down alternative and feather toppers are ideal for those who prefer a softer, more plush feel. Additionally, it's important to consider the size of your mattress and the thickness of the topper to ensure a proper fit.

We spent hours researching and testing various pillow top mattress toppers to identify the best options on the market. In this article, we will share our top picks and provide a comprehensive guide to help you make an informed decision on the best pillow top mattress topper for your needs.

Top 3 Best Pillow Top Mattress Toppers

  1. Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Memory Foam Mattress Topper
  2. CYMULA Mattress Topper Queen
  3. HYPREST Extra Thick Mattress Topper Queen

We understand that getting a good night's sleep is essential for your overall well-being. That's why we've researched and tested the best pillow top mattress toppers on the market to help you find the perfect one for your needs. Our list includes a variety of options, from budget-friendly to luxurious, to suit any preference. Whether you're looking to add extra comfort to your current mattress or revamp your sleep experience entirely, we've got you covered. So, without further ado, here are our top picks for the best pillow top mattress toppers.

Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Memory Foam Mattress Topper

The Editor's Choice

The Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Memory Foam Mattress Topper transformed our sleep game! Luxuriously soft cover meets supportive gel memory foam, plus easy cleaning. Install securely for better sleep, but not ideal for firm enthusiasts. Invest in improved sleep with a 10-year warranty – no regrets.

See Price on Amazon

We highly recommend the Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Memory Foam Mattress Topper for those who want to add extra comfort to their mattress.

Pros

  • The 2-inch soft quilted pillow top cover with plush fiber fill provides a luxurious feel.
  • The 2 inches of cooling gel memory foam offer medium support and relieve pressure points.
  • The pillow top cover is removable, washable, and stretches to fit your bed like a fitted sheet.

Cons

  • The topper may be too soft for those who prefer a firmer feel.
  • The gel memory foam may take some time to fully expand and air out.
  • The topper may retain heat for some users.

We found the Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Memory Foam Mattress Topper to be an excellent addition to our bed. The pillow top cover is soft and comfortable, while the gel memory foam provides just the right amount of support. We appreciated the removable and washable cover, which made it easy to keep our bed clean and fresh.

The topper is easy to install and fits securely on our mattress. We noticed a significant improvement in our sleep quality, as the topper relieved pressure points and reduced motion transfer. However, the topper may not be suitable for those who prefer a firmer feel.

Overall, we think the Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Memory Foam Mattress Topper is a great investment for anyone looking to improve their sleep experience. With its high-quality materials and 10-year warranty, it's a purchase you won't regret.

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend the CYMULA Mattress Topper Queen for anyone looking to add extra comfort to their bed.

Pros

  • The mattress topper is incredibly soft and fluffy, providing a comfortable sleeping experience.
  • The high-quality cotton surface is breathable and gentle on the skin.
  • The deep pockets and durable stitching ensure the topper stays securely in place without any noise or movement.

Cons

  • The mattress topper may not be thick enough for those who prefer a very plush sleeping surface.
  • Some users have reported that the topper may slide around on the bed.
  • It may take some time to fluff up the topper after opening it from its packaging.

We were impressed with the CYMULA Mattress Topper Queen's softness and comfort. The polyester layer and filling provide just the right amount of support for the body, ensuring a good night's sleep. The 100% cotton surface is breathable, making it ideal for those who tend to get hot at night. Additionally, the deep pockets and durable stitching ensure that the topper stays securely in place on the mattress.

However, we did notice that the topper may not be thick enough for those who prefer a very plush sleeping surface. Some users have also reported that the topper may slide around on the bed, which can be a bit frustrating. Finally, it may take some time to fluff up the topper after opening it from its packaging.

Overall, we believe that the CYMULA Mattress Topper Queen is a great option for anyone looking to add some extra comfort to their bed. It's soft, breathable, and durable, making it a great investment for anyone looking to improve their sleep quality.

See Price on Amazon

We highly recommend the HYPREST Extra Thick Mattress Topper Queen for anyone looking to upgrade their old mattress with a cloud-like plush down alternative mattress topper.

Pros

  • The extra thick 1300 GSM 5D snow down alternative fiber filling provides superior comfort and pressure relief, minimizing back and hip pain.
  • The 100% organic cotton shell wicks away moisture and provides a soft and durable surface for a comfortable night's sleep.
  • The non-slip, all-around stretchable elastic skirt fits any mattress up to 24" deep, ensuring a snug fit and preventing the topper from popping off at the corners.

Cons

  • The mattress topper may look thinner after opening, but can be fluffed up quickly by shaking and leaving it for several hours.
  • The fitted sides could be a little tighter for a more secure fit.
  • The topper is not water-resistant.

The HYPREST Extra Thick Mattress Topper Queen is an excellent choice for anyone looking to add a fluffy and comfortable layer to their mattress. The extra thick 1300 GSM 5D snow down alternative fiber filling provides superior comfort and pressure relief, minimizing back and hip pain. The 100% organic cotton shell wicks away moisture and provides a soft and durable surface for a comfortable night's sleep. The non-slip, all-around stretchable elastic skirt fits any mattress up to 24" deep, ensuring a snug fit and preventing the topper from popping off at the corners.

Although the mattress topper may look thinner after opening, it can be fluffed up quickly by shaking and leaving it for several hours. The fitted sides could be a little tighter for a more secure fit. Additionally, the topper is not water-resistant. However, overall, the HYPREST Extra Thick Mattress Topper Queen is a great investment for anyone looking to upgrade their sleeping experience.

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend the HYLEORY Queen Mattress Pad for anyone looking to improve their sleep quality with added comfort and breathability.

Pros

  • The microfiber top makes the surface feel cooling and breathable, providing a comfortable sleeping environment.
  • The 360° fabric sides easily stretch to fit mattresses up to 21" thick, ensuring a secure fit that won't slide around.
  • The quilted mattress pad cover is durable and the square jacquard prevents the filling from running around.

Cons

  • The padding is thin, so it may not provide enough added comfort for those with very firm mattresses.
  • The mattress pad may take some time to puff up and expand after being removed from packaging.
  • The white color may show stains and dirt more easily than darker colored mattress pads.

We were impressed with how breathable and comfortable the HYLEORY Queen Mattress Pad is, thanks to its microfiber top and fluffy filling. The deep pocket design ensures a secure fit on a variety of mattress types, and the durable quilted cover adds an extra layer of protection to your mattress.

Overall, we believe the HYLEORY Queen Mattress Pad is a great investment for anyone looking to improve their sleep quality with added comfort and breathability.

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend purchasing the HYLEORY Extra Thick Mattress Topper if you're looking for a comfortable and durable addition to your bedding.

Pros

  • The 3D snow down alternative overfilling provides excellent softness and support for a comfortable night's sleep.
  • The cloud-like surface with 3D&7D Fiber made Three Dimensional Structure promotes air circulation, keeping you cool and comfortable throughout the night.
  • The stretchable knitted skirt design with a no-slip back ensures a secure fit on mattresses up to 21 inches deep.

Cons

  • The mattress topper is not as thick as it appears in the product image.
  • The filling is not as plush as some users may prefer.
  • The mattress topper may not be suitable for those who prefer a firmer sleeping surface.

We were impressed with the HYLEORY Extra Thick Mattress Topper's luxurious feel and its ability to keep us cool throughout the night. The mattress topper is also easy to care for and durable, making it a great investment for any bedroom.

The only downside we found with the HYLEORY Extra Thick Mattress Topper is that it is not as thick as it appears in the product image. Additionally, the filling may not be as plush as some users prefer, and it may not be suitable for those who prefer a firmer sleeping surface.

Overall, we highly recommend the HYLEORY Extra Thick Mattress Topper for anyone looking to add a comfortable and durable layer to their mattress.

See price on Amazon

If you're looking for a comfortable and affordable way to upgrade your mattress, Oaskys Pillow Top Mattress Topper is a great option.

Pros

  • The 4D down alternative filling provides superior comfort without extra heat and sweat.
  • The optimum thickness of the mattress pad provides a perfect balance between softness and support.
  • The top layer of microfiber is ultra-soft, fresh, and breathable, which keeps your skin cozy and cool.

Cons

  • The mattress topper may not be thick enough for those who prefer an extra soft and fluffy feel.
  • The elastic bands may not fit tightly enough for some mattresses.
  • The mattress topper may take some time to fluff up after unpacking.

We've been using the Oaskys Pillow Top Mattress Topper for a few weeks now and have been impressed with its comfort and durability. The 4D down alternative filling feels like authentic goose and down, providing a soft and cozy sleeping experience without the extra heat and sweat. The mattress pad's thickness strikes a perfect balance between softness and support, making it suitable for all types of sleepers.

The microfiber top layer is ultra-soft, fresh, and breathable, which keeps your skin cozy and cool throughout the night. The mattress topper's fluffy texture provides an extra layer of softness, enhancing our sleep quality and making us feel like we're sleeping on a cloud.

The Oaskys Pillow Top Mattress Topper is equipped with a 360° all-around elastic skirt and four no-slip elastic anchor bands that wrap around the mattress tightly, ensuring a secure fit. The deep pockets fit and grip any mattress up to 21", making it a convenient and durable product.

Overall, we highly recommend the Oaskys Pillow Top Mattress Topper to anyone looking for an affordable and comfortable way to upgrade their mattress. It's machine washable and comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee, making it a risk-free purchase.

See price on Amazon

If you're looking for a comfortable and supportive mattress topper, the Timimi Mattress Topper Queen is a great option.

Pros

  • The microfiber fabric is soft and breathable, making it comfortable to sleep on in all seasons.
  • The down alternative hollow fiber filling is soft, fluffy, and offers strong support and resilience.
  • The mattress topper fits mattresses of all sizes and has 4 stable anchor elastic straps to ensure a secure fit.

Cons

  • The mattress topper is not very cooling, so it may not be the best option for hot sleepers.
  • The filling may shift slightly over time, but the box quilting construction helps prevent this.
  • The mattress topper may have a slight odor when first unpacked, but this will dissipate after a few days.

We recently tried out the Timimi Mattress Topper Queen and were impressed with its comfort and support. The microfiber fabric is soft and breathable, making it comfortable to sleep on in all seasons. The down alternative hollow fiber filling is also very soft and fluffy, but still offers strong support and resilience. We appreciated that the mattress topper fits mattresses of all sizes and has 4 stable anchor elastic straps to ensure a secure fit.

While the mattress topper is not very cooling, we did not find it to be overly warm either. However, it may not be the best option for hot sleepers. We did notice that the filling may shift slightly over time, but the box quilting construction helps prevent this. Additionally, the mattress topper may have a slight odor when first unpacked, but this will dissipate after a few days.

Overall, we would recommend the Timimi Mattress Topper Queen to anyone looking for a comfortable and supportive mattress topper. It's a great option for those who want to add extra comfort to their firm mattress and reduce stress on their neck, back, and shoulders.

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend the Marine Moon Mattress Topper Queen for anyone looking to add a cloud-like comfort to their bed.

Pros

  • The overfilled plush luxury down alternative fill provides ultra comfort for all sleeping positions.
  • The 3-inch bed topper is 50% thicker than the average mattress pillow topper, providing the best relief and support for pressure points.
  • The 400TC cooling premium top fabric makes you feel cooling and skin-friendly, maximizes comfort and temperature regulation for the restorative sleep possible.

Cons

  • The topper may be too soft for those who prefer a firmer sleeping surface.
  • The topper may retain heat and feel too warm for some users.
  • The topper cannot be machine washed and must be dry cleaned only.

The Marine Moon Mattress Topper Queen is the perfect addition to a firm latex or memory foam mattress. The overfilled cushion provides the best relief and support for pressure points like your shoulders, back, and hips. The extra thick layer delivers instant relaxation, helping you fall and stay asleep. The 400TC cooling premium top fabric makes you feel cool and skin-friendly, maximizing comfort and temperature regulation for the restorative sleep possible.

The baffle box pattern design helps to keep the feather and down filling from shifting, and the mattress pad topper has four double anchor bands adapting to mattress depths up to 18", helping keep the plush mattress topper in one place. Cheaper and easier to store than a mattress, it's a must for renters!

The Marine Moon Mattress Topper Queen is packaged in a vacuum bag, so it needs to be spread for a few days before use so the feather bed topper would return to normal thickness. (Best Way Fluffy Again: Put mattress topper in a tumble dryer on low heat & low speed for 15 minutes or lay it in the Sun for a Few Hours.) The 30-night trial allows you to test the thick mattress topper with no risk!

See price on Amazon

If you are looking for a comfortable and soft mattress topper, then D & G THE DUCK AND GOOSE CO Plush Extra Thick Mattress Topper Queen is the perfect choice for you.

Pros

  • The mattress topper is generously filled with 153oz super soft down alternative gel-fiber, which makes it extra thick and offers the ultimate in softness to provide cloud-like sleep comfort to your body during the night.
  • Featuring breathable down alternative gel-fiber filling and skin-friendly soft brushed polyester fabric, this mattress topper is a great solution for people who are sensitive to feather-down mattress toppers or suffering from the odors or the heat retaining of a memory foam mattress topper.
  • The generously filled and evenly distributed gel-fiber filling adds an extra layer of thick cushion on your mattress delivering instant relaxation and providing best relief and support to shoulders, back, and hips. It is ideal for side, back or stomach sleepers and can greatly relieve the back pain.

Cons

  • The mattress topper may not be as puffy as described, and it has not really relieved any hip pain.
  • It is not as thick as what’s been advertised.
  • It's not as soft and cushy as hoped.

We have used D & G THE DUCK AND GOOSE CO Plush Extra Thick Mattress Topper Queen, and we are happy with its performance. The mattress topper is ultra-comfortable, and it provides excellent support to the body. The gel-fiber filling is evenly distributed, and it adds an extra layer of cushion to the mattress. The mattress topper is perfect for people who are looking for a soft and comfortable sleeping surface.

The mattress topper comes with 4 corner elastic straps that adapt to mattress depths from 6" to 22" and ensures a secure fit to allow you to toss and turn freely. The box quilting construction prevents the fillings from shifting as you sleep to offer you the most consistent comfort.

To extend your bed topper’s life and reduce the need to wash it, position a mattress protector/fitted sheet over it. Wash bi-annually in a front loader machine on a cool wash. *Please do not use a top loader machine as the agitators destroy the fibers.

Buying Guide

When looking for the best pillow top mattress topper, there are a few key features to consider. Here are some factors to keep in mind when making your purchase:

Material

The material of the mattress topper is an important consideration. Different materials offer different levels of support and comfort. Memory foam is a popular choice for its ability to contour to your body and relieve pressure points. Latex is another option that provides good support and is naturally hypoallergenic. Wool and down are also popular choices for their softness and ability to regulate temperature.

Thickness

The thickness of the mattress topper can have a big impact on its comfort level. A thicker topper will generally provide more cushioning and support, while a thinner topper may be more suitable for those who prefer a firmer feel. It's important to consider your personal preferences and any existing back or joint pain when choosing the thickness of your mattress topper.

Size

Make sure to choose a mattress topper that fits your bed properly. Measure your mattress before making your purchase to ensure a good fit. Keep in mind that some toppers may shrink slightly after being unpacked, so it's a good idea to choose a size slightly larger than your mattress.

Durability

The durability of the mattress topper is also an important consideration. Look for a topper made from high-quality materials that will stand up to regular use. It's also a good idea to read reviews and check the warranty to ensure you're getting a product that will last.

Price

Mattress toppers can vary greatly in price, so it's important to consider your budget when making your purchase. Keep in mind that a higher price doesn't always mean better quality. Look for a mattress topper that offers the features you need at a price you can afford.

In summary, when choosing the best pillow top mattress topper, consider the material, thickness, size, durability, and price. By keeping these factors in mind, you can find a topper that will provide the comfort and support you need for a good night's sleep.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the highest rated cooling mattress topper?

The highest rated cooling mattress topper is the Sleep Innovations 4-inch Dual Layer Mattress Topper. It features a quilted fiberfill cover with two layers of cooling gel memory foam for maximum comfort and support.

What's the difference between a pillow top and a memory foam mattress topper?

A pillow top mattress topper is typically made of soft materials like down, cotton, or wool, while a memory foam mattress topper is made of viscoelastic foam that conforms to your body shape. Memory foam toppers provide more support and pressure relief, while pillow top toppers offer more plushness and comfort.

Which is better for back pain, a pillow top or memory foam mattress topper?

Both pillow top and memory foam mattress toppers can help alleviate back pain, but memory foam toppers are generally better at providing support and pressure relief. If you have severe back pain, a memory foam topper may be the best option.

Are there any mattress toppers that don't sink in?

Yes, there are mattress toppers that don't sink in. Latex mattress toppers are a great option for those who want a firm and supportive surface to sleep on. They are also hypoallergenic and durable, making them a great investment.

What are the benefits of a Saatva mattress topper?

A Saatva mattress topper is made of high-quality materials that are designed to provide maximum comfort and support. It is also hypoallergenic, eco-friendly, and made in the USA. Additionally, Saatva offers a 45-day trial period and free shipping and returns.

Is the Costco mattress topper worth the investment?

The Costco mattress topper is a great investment for those who want a comfortable and supportive sleeping surface. It is made of high-density memory foam and features a removable, machine-washable cover. Additionally, Costco offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee and free shipping and returns.

Affiliate Disclosure:
The links provided may earn us a small commission at no additional cost to you if you choose to purchase the recommended product. This support allows our research and editorial team to continue providing high-quality recommendations. As a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising initiative, we are able to earn advertising fees through providing links to products on Amazon.com. Please rest assured that we only recommend high-quality products.