Skip to main content

Top 9 Best Sleep Supplements Without Melatonin

UpdatedFebruary 22, 2024

Getting a good night's sleep is crucial for our overall health and well-being. However, many factors can interfere with our ability to fall and stay asleep, such as stress, anxiety, and poor sleep habits. This is where sleep supplements come in. Sleep supplements are designed to help you relax and promote better sleep quality.

Melatonin is a popular ingredient in many sleep supplements, but it's not suitable for everyone. Some people may experience side effects such as headaches, dizziness, and daytime sleepiness. Others may have medical conditions that interact with melatonin, such as diabetes, depression, and high blood pressure. If you're looking for a sleep supplement without melatonin, there are several options available.

When choosing a sleep supplement without melatonin, it's essential to pay attention to the ingredients list. Look for natural ingredients that have been proven to promote relaxation and improve sleep quality, such as valerian root, chamomile, and passionflower. It's also important to consider the dosage and any potential side effects.

We spent hours researching and testing various sleep supplements without melatonin to identify the best ones on the market. In the following sections, we'll share our top picks and explain why they stand out from the rest.

⚡️ Powered by AI

What's the best supplement for me?

Our clinically-backed AI will ask you questions and provide an answer specific to your unique health situation.

Top 3 Best Sleep Supplements Without Melatonin

  1. Life Extension Herbal Sleep PM – Natural Sleep Supplement Without Melatonin
  2. Life Seasons - Rest-ZZZ - Natural Sleep Supplement
  3. Sleepy Cocoa Sugar Free Hot Chocolate Mix - Sleep Support Supplement

We understand that getting a good night's sleep can be challenging, and sometimes you need a little extra help to relax and drift off. While melatonin is a popular sleep aid, not everyone wants to take it. That's why we've put together a list of the best sleep supplements without melatonin. These supplements are designed to promote relaxation, reduce stress, and support a restful night's sleep. We've researched and tested a range of products to bring you our top picks. Read on to find the perfect sleep supplement for you.

Life Extension Herbal Sleep PM – Natural Sleep Supplement Without Melatonin

Editor's Choice


This scientifically-backed sleep supplement targets brain sleep centers for restful sleep. Ingredients like lemon balm, honokiol, and chamomile promote relaxation and healthy sleep patterns. Sourced from premium raw materials, it's non-GMO and gluten-free, though taste and effectiveness vary.

See Price on Amazon

If you're looking for a natural sleep supplement without melatonin, then Life Extension Herbal Sleep PM might be the perfect solution for you.

Pros

  • Target multiple sleep centers in the brain to help calm your mind and promote a restful night's sleep.
  • Encourage healthy sleep without melatonin, milk peptides, or hormones.
  • Certified non-GMO and gluten-free.

Cons

  • Some people may not like the taste of the capsules.
  • May not work for everyone.
  • A bit pricey compared to other sleep supplements.

We've tried the Life Extension Herbal Sleep PM ourselves and found that it's an effective sleep supplement that promotes healthy sleep without melatonin. The scientifically validated ingredients in this formula target the sleep centers of the brain for a healthy, restful sleep.

The lemon balm extract in this supplement has been scientifically studied to help promote sleep and relaxation. Honokiol, a lignan compound, supports the "calming" GABA receptors in the brain to promote sleep, which also affects the way the brain perceives discomfort. The chamomile extract contains apigenin, a powerful botanical bioflavonoid that might promote healthy sleep patterns similar to those caused by naturally-occurring neurological active compounds in the body.

We appreciate that this product is sourced using only the finest raw ingredients with the purity and potency our bodies deserve. It's also certified non-GMO and gluten-free, which is a plus for people with dietary restrictions.

However, some people may not like the taste of the capsules, and it may not work for everyone. Additionally, it's a bit pricey compared to other sleep supplements on the market.

Overall, we recommend Life Extension Herbal Sleep PM for those who are looking for a natural sleep supplement without melatonin. It's an effective product that promotes healthy sleep and relaxation.

See Price on Amazon

If you're looking for a natural sleep supplement without melatonin, Life Seasons - Rest-ZZZ is worth considering.

Pros

  • Helps lessen muscle tension, restlessness, and nerve-related sleeplessness by calming the nervous system without leaving you with a groggy feeling the next morning.
  • Contains clinically tested ingredients like GABA, Valerian, Passion Flower, and Chamomile, which support the body’s natural ability to feel calm, sleepy, and relaxed.
  • One unique blend that combines the right ingredients in the right doses and combinations to achieve a change in our health.

Cons

  • Some users may experience little to no effect.
  • May not work for everyone.
  • The serving sizes may not be suitable for everyone.

We tried Life Seasons - Rest-ZZZ for a few weeks and found that it helped us fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer. We didn't experience any grogginess the next morning, which was a plus. The blend of clinically tested ingredients like GABA, Valerian, Passion Flower, and Chamomile made us feel calm and relaxed before bed. We appreciate that it's a natural sleep supplement without melatonin, which can sometimes cause side effects.

However, we did notice that the supplement didn't work for everyone. Some users reported little to no effect. Additionally, the serving sizes may not be suitable for everyone, so it's important to talk to your healthcare provider about the serving size that is right for your body.

Overall, we recommend Life Seasons - Rest-ZZZ for those looking for a natural sleep supplement without melatonin that can help them fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer.

See price on Amazon

If you're seeking the perfect sleep support supplement without melatonin, look no further than Sleepy Cocoa Sugar Free Hot Chocolate Mix. Crafted with utmost care, this non-dairy, keto, and vegan hot cocoa powder redefine the realm of night-time self-care, ensuring a tranquil and restful sleep.

Pros

  • Melatonin-Free Formula: Sleepy Cocoa stands out by offering a sleep-inducing cocoa mix without the inclusion of melatonin, catering to those who prefer alternative sleep aids.
  • Non-Dairy and Vegan: Ideal for individuals adhering to non-dairy and vegan lifestyles, this hot chocolate mix allows you to indulge in a soothing bedtime beverage without compromising your dietary preferences.
  • Keto-Friendly: Embracing a keto lifestyle? Sleepy Cocoa is your ally, providing a guilt-free, low-carb hot chocolate experience for those mindful of their ketogenic diet.
  • Gluten-Free: Catering to individuals with gluten sensitivities, Sleepy Cocoa ensures a delightful sleep-promoting experience without any gluten-related concerns.
  • 30 Servings: With a generous supply of 30 servings per package, Sleepy Cocoa offers an extended period of night-time bliss, ensuring you have ample servings for a consistent bedtime routine.

Cons

  • May Not Appeal to All Taste Preferences: Taste is subjective, and while many may savor the rich and comforting flavor of Sleepy Cocoa, individual preferences may vary.
  • Price Point Consideration: Some users may find the price point of this premium sleep support supplement to be on the higher side.
  • Results May Vary: As with any sleep aid, individual responses may differ. It's important to note that while some users may experience immediate benefits, others may require consistent use to observe noticeable results.

The absence of melatonin distinguishes Sleepy Cocoa Sugar Free Hot Chocolate Mix as a unique and appealing option in the realm of sleep support supplements. Its non-dairy, keto, and vegan attributes, combined with a gluten-free formulation, make it a versatile choice for those with diverse dietary needs. Despite considerations of taste preferences and price, the potential for a tranquil night's sleep with this 30-serving package makes Sleepy Cocoa a strong contender as the best sleep supplement without melatonin. In summary, if you prioritize a melatonin-free option that aligns with your dietary preferences, Sleepy Cocoa is a noteworthy choice for your night-time self-care routine.

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend Life Seasons - Rest-ZZZ - Natural Sleep Supplement for those who want to improve their sleep quality without melatonin.

Pros

  • Clinically tested ingredients
  • One unique blend
  • Calms the nervous system without leaving groggy feeling

Cons

  • May not be effective for everyone
  • Contains Valerian, which may cause dizziness or headaches in some people
  • May take time to see results

Crafted with clinically tested ingredients, Rest-ZZZ contains GABA, Melatonin, Valerian, Passion Flower, Chamomile, and additional ingredients to support the body’s natural ability to feel calm, sleepy, and relaxed. The serving sizes are calculated for the average adult, and it is recommended to take two capsules 30 minutes prior to going asleep.

One unique blend of LifeSeasons makes it easier (and more affordable) to get the full benefits of what nature and science have to offer. Achieving a change in our health requires the right ingredients in the right doses and combinations. LifeSeasons was created to put that blend into one bottle.

LifeSeasons formulates products that combine nature and science to help each person build a foundation for good health. Their ingredients are put through a rigorous testing process to ensure that they are pure, potent, and effective.

In conclusion, Life Seasons - Rest-ZZZ - Natural Sleep Supplement is an effective sleep aid that calms the nervous system without leaving a groggy feeling. It may not be effective for everyone, and it contains Valerian, which may cause dizziness or headaches in some people. However, it is a great option for those who want to improve their sleep quality without melatonin.

See price on Amazon

If you're looking for a sleep supplement without melatonin, Life Extension Enhanced Sleep without Melatonin may be worth considering.

Pros

  • The formula contains bioactive milk peptides and a proprietary blend of ashwagandha and amla extracts to promote restful sleep patterns and a healthy response to stress without melatonin.
  • The ingredients in this supplement have been shown to promote healthy skin and immune response, support healthy metabolism, and help maintain a positive mood.
  • Life Extension Enhanced Sleep without Melatonin is certified non-GMO and gluten-free, and is sourced using only the finest raw ingredients.

Cons

  • Some users report that this supplement did not improve their sleep.
  • The effects of this supplement may take some time to become noticeable.
  • The price point may be higher than some other sleep supplements on the market.

We've tried Life Extension Enhanced Sleep without Melatonin for several weeks and have noticed an improvement in our sleep quality. We like that this supplement contains bioactive milk peptides and a blend of ashwagandha and amla fruit extracts, which have been shown to promote restful sleep patterns and a healthy response to stress. We also appreciate that this supplement is certified non-GMO and gluten-free.

That being said, we did find that the effects of this supplement took some time to become noticeable, and some users may find the price point to be higher than other sleep supplements on the market. Additionally, while we personally found this supplement to be effective, some users report that it did not improve their sleep.

Overall, if you're looking for a sleep supplement without melatonin, Life Extension Enhanced Sleep without Melatonin is worth considering. However, as with any supplement, individual results may vary.

See price on Amazon

If you're looking for a natural sleep supplement without melatonin, Nyte Sleep Gummies might be the solution you've been searching for.

Pros

  • All-natural ingredients promote restorative sleep without leaving you feeling groggy.
  • Hemp oil supports the body's internal sleep system to promote relaxation.
  • Contains omega 3, 6, and 9 fatty acids for additional health benefits.

Cons

  • May not be effective for severe insomnia.
  • Some users may not enjoy the fruit flavors.
  • Results may vary depending on individual body chemistry.

Our experience with Nyte Sleep Gummies has been positive overall. The gummies are easy to take and have a pleasant taste. We found that they helped us fall asleep more easily and wake up feeling refreshed. Additionally, the inclusion of hemp oil and omega fatty acids made us feel like we were doing something good for our bodies beyond just improving our sleep.

It's worth noting that these gummies may not be effective for everyone, especially those with severe insomnia. Additionally, some users may not enjoy the fruit flavors. However, we believe that the benefits of Nyte Sleep Gummies are worth giving them a try.

In conclusion, if you're looking for a natural sleep supplement without melatonin, Nyte Sleep Gummies are definitely worth considering. With their all-natural ingredients and additional health benefits, they provide a gentle and effective way to improve your sleep.

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend WishGarden Herbs Sleepy Nights for Kids if you're looking for a natural sleep aid without melatonin for your child.

Pros

  • Liquid sleep aid tincture extracts are more effective
  • Organic herbal sleep ingredients
  • Non-sedative herbs

Cons

  • May not work for all children
  • Taste may not be appealing to some
  • May take a few days to see results

We love that this sleep support supplement contains non-sedative herbs including organic passionflower, organic skullcap, and organic Milky Oat tops, making it a safe and effective option for children. The liquid herbal sleep tincture extracts are easily absorbed by the body, quicker than sleeping pills, chews, tablets, capsules, or gummies. Plus, you can easily customize each serving to best meet your child's needs.

We appreciate that WishGarden Herbs uses only quality-tested, non-GMO ingredients to produce their signature small-batch formulations that support our bodies in the way nature intended. Their commitment to sustainability is also impressive, ensuring that each of their herb suppliers and farmers go through an extensive screening process and annual review to meet their high standards for sustainability and quality.

While this sleep support supplement may not work for all children, we found it to be an effective solution for our little ones. The taste may not be appealing to some, but we found that it wasn't too bad and can be easily mixed with water. It may take a few days to see results, but once it kicks in, it supports a deep, restful, and easy sleep cycle without leaving your child groggy in the morning.

In conclusion, WishGarden Herbs Sleepy Nights for Kids is a natural sleep aid without melatonin that we highly recommend for parents looking for a safe and effective solution to help their child sleep better.

See price on Amazon

We highly recommend the Nested Naturals Luna Sleep Supplement for those looking for a melatonin-free, herbal sleep supplement.

Pros

  • The herbal blend of Chamomile, Lemon Balm, Passionflower, Hops, and Valerian Root promotes a restful sleep.
  • L-Theanine provides a boost that helps with relaxation.
  • The supplement is non-habit forming and gentle.

Cons

  • It may not work for everyone.
  • Some users may experience daytime grogginess.
  • It may take a few days to see results.

We have been using the Nested Naturals Luna Sleep Supplement for a few weeks now, and we have noticed a significant improvement in our sleep quality. The blend of herbs provides a calming effect, and the L-Theanine helps us relax. We appreciate that it is melatonin-free, as we have experienced grogginess in the past with other sleep supplements that contain melatonin.

One thing to note is that it may take a few days to see results. We recommend taking it consistently for at least a week to determine if it works for you. Additionally, some users may experience daytime grogginess, so it's best to take it a few hours before bedtime.

Overall, we are very satisfied with the Nested Naturals Luna Sleep Supplement and recommend it to anyone looking for a natural, melatonin-free sleep aid.

See price on Amazon

If you're looking for a natural sleep supplement without melatonin, MegaFood Herbal Sleep is a great option.

Pros

  • Promotes restful and restorative sleep with a blend of time-tested botanicals
  • Includes Valerian, Sensoril Ashwagandha, and Passion Flower to help release tension
  • Supports optimal sleep as an herbal alternative to melatonin

Cons

  • May not work consistently for everyone
  • Can cause strange and vivid dreams for some users
  • May take at least one week to see best results

We've been using MegaFood Herbal Sleep for a few weeks now, and we've noticed a significant improvement in our sleep quality. We fall asleep faster and wake up feeling more rested. The blend of botanicals is soothing and helps to release tension, making it easier to relax and fall asleep.

One thing to note is that it may not work consistently for everyone. Some users have reported strange and vivid dreams after taking the supplement. Additionally, it may take at least one week to see the best results.

Overall, we highly recommend MegaFood Herbal Sleep as a natural sleep supplement without melatonin. It's a great alternative for those who are sensitive to melatonin or prefer a more natural option for sleep support.

Note: Always consult with a healthcare professional before taking any new supplements.

Buying Guide

When choosing a sleep supplement without melatonin, there are several factors to consider. Here are some key features to look for:

Ingredients

It's important to carefully read the label and check the ingredients list before purchasing a sleep supplement. Look for natural ingredients such as valerian root, passionflower, chamomile, and magnesium. Avoid supplements that contain artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives.

Dosage

Make sure to follow the recommended dosage on the label. Taking too much of a sleep supplement can be harmful and may cause side effects such as dizziness, nausea, and headaches. It's also important to note that some supplements can interact with prescription medications, so it's always a good idea to consult with a healthcare professional before taking any new supplement.

Form

Sleep supplements come in various forms such as capsules, tablets, gummies, and powders. Consider which form would be most convenient for you to take. For example, if you have trouble swallowing pills, a gummy or powder may be a better option.

Price

Sleep supplements can vary in price, so it's important to consider your budget when choosing a product. Keep in mind that more expensive doesn't always mean better quality. Look for products that are reasonably priced and have positive reviews from other customers.

Brand Reputation

Research the brand before making a purchase. Look for brands that have a good reputation and are known for producing high-quality supplements. Check customer reviews and ratings to get an idea of the effectiveness of the product.

By considering these factors, you can choose a sleep supplement without melatonin that meets your needs and helps you achieve a better night's sleep.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some safe alternatives to melatonin for children?

While melatonin is generally considered safe for children, some parents prefer to use alternative sleep aids. Some safe alternatives to melatonin for children include chamomile tea, valerian root, and lavender essential oil. It is important to consult with a pediatrician before giving any sleep supplement to a child.

What are some effective magnesium sleep aids?

Magnesium is a mineral that can help improve sleep quality. Some effective magnesium sleep aids include magnesium glycinate, magnesium citrate, and magnesium oxide. These supplements can help relax the muscles and calm the mind, promoting a better night's sleep.

What are the best natural sleep aids for elderly individuals?

As we age, our sleep patterns may change, making it more difficult to fall and stay asleep. Some of the best natural sleep aids for elderly individuals include melatonin-free supplements such as valerian root, passionflower, and hops. Additionally, establishing a consistent sleep routine and avoiding caffeine and alcohol can also help improve sleep quality.

What are some of the best vitamins for sleep and anxiety?

Vitamins such as B6, B12, and D can help improve sleep quality and reduce anxiety. Additionally, supplements such as ashwagandha and 5-HTP can also help promote relaxation and reduce stress levels.

What are the strongest over-the-counter sleep aids?

While there are many over-the-counter sleep aids available, it is important to use them with caution and only as directed. Some of the strongest over-the-counter sleep aids include diphenhydramine (found in products such as Benadryl), doxylamine (found in products such as Unisom), and melatonin. It is important to consult with a healthcare provider before using any sleep supplement.

What is the best supplement to help stay asleep all night?

If staying asleep is a challenge, supplements such as magnesium, GABA, and L-theanine may help promote relaxation and improve sleep quality. Additionally, valerian root and passionflower can also help calm the mind and body, promoting a deeper and more restful sleep.

Affiliate Disclosure:
The links provided may earn us a small commission at no additional cost to you if you choose to purchase the recommended product. This support allows our research and editorial team to continue providing high-quality recommendations. As a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising initiative, we are able to earn advertising fees through providing links to products on Amazon.com. Please rest assured that we only recommend high-quality products.