Knee Instability Symptoms, Causes & Common Questions

The feeling of a loose knee cap is most commonly caused by an injury that has sprained or tore ligaments. A meniscal or anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury can also cause knee instability and pain. Read below for more information about causes and how to seek medical treatment for an unstable knee.

Knee Instability Symptom Checker

Take a quiz to find out what might be causing your knee instability

Contents

  1. Symptoms
  2. Causes
  3. 8 Possible Knee Instability Conditions
  4. Treatments and Relief
  5. Real-Life Stories
  6. Questions Your Doctor May Ask
  7. Statistics
  8. Related Articles

Knee Instability Symptoms

Ligaments are the tough fibrous bands that hold the bones together. If the ligaments within the knee become damaged, the knee joint will be painful, wobbly, and unstable. It may feel as though it could give way at any moment while you are walking, exercising, or even just standing.

If the muscles of the knee are damaged, they cannot contract properly, and you will experience weakness and pain. Swelling may have the same effect.

Knee injuries are usually sports injuries, though they can happen during any physical activity that leads to twisting of the knee or to a traumatic injury of the joint.

Common characteristics of knee instability

The following can likely describe your knee instability.

  • Your knee feels out of place: The sensation that the knee is popping out of place, or is about to collapse under you.
  • Looseness: The sensation that the structures within the knee are loose.
  • Knee locking: Feeling that the knee joint is locking or catching.
  • A pop in the knee: Feeling, or even hearing, a popping or clicking from the knee.
  • Finding it impossible to straighten the knee
  • Pain: This may be mild, moderate, or quite severe.
  • Swelling

Who is most often affected by knee instability symptoms

The following individuals are more likely to experience knee instability.

  • Young athletes: Fit, active athletes in their teens and twenties are the ones who most often suffer sports injuries.
  • Dancers
  • Anyone doing hard physical labor
  • Anyone who is overweight or obese
  • Women: Women may be more prone to knee problems, due to naturally having a wider pelvis. Therefore, women have a predisposition to misalignment between the top of the kneecap and the bottom of the thighbone.
  • Older people: May experience gradual wearing away of the cartilage of the knee
  • If you have a prior injury: This can predispose you to another one.

When are knee instability symptoms most likely to occur?

The following situations can result in either acute or chronic knee instability.

  • Acute injury: This can occur when playing sports, when falling down, or during an automobile accident.
  • Chronic pain: This can occur with mild exercise or while climbing up and down stairs.

Are knee instability symptoms serious?

The severity of your knee instability is ultimately dependent on the cause and the impact it has on your activity levels or quality of life.

  • Not serious: A mild strain or sprain is a common sports injury and can be healed with rest and physical therapy.
  • Moderately serious: Damage to the cartilage can lead to arthritis. The pain and instability of an acute injury may become chronic if not treated right away.
  • Serious: A more severe injury, if neglected, can suddenly worsen if you overdo it. For example, a partial tear may become a complete tear.

Knee Instability Causes

Most common knee instability causes

The most common causes of knee instability include the following.

  • Ligament sprain: Sprain of the knee ligaments, which means these ligaments have had their fibers damaged due to wear and tear, sudden stress, or direct trauma.
  • Ligament tear: Tear of the ligaments, meaning the fibers have been partially or completely torn through. This usually happens when you run and then make a sudden change of direction the knee stays pointing one way while the rest of you twists the other way.

Less common knee instability causes

Causes of knee instability that are less common include the following.

  • Muscle damage: Inability of the damaged muscle to physically contract properly
  • Fluid buildup from the injury: Thus interfering with muscle action

Rare and unusual knee instability causes

Causes of knee instability that occur even less frequently include the following.

  • Partial dislocation: If you do something strenuous enough to damage the ligaments, it is likely that you will have damage to the cartilage around the knee bone as well. The patella, or kneecap, can become partially or completely dislocated. A partial dislocation is called a subluxation. Dislocation can occur if the ligaments are damaged and are not holding the kneecap firmly in place as usual.
  • Cartilage tears: The cartilage at the ends of the upper and lower leg bones, which meet under the kneecap, can become torn. This often happens along with a ligament sprain.
  • Cartilage wear: Cartilage can gradually wear away over time, causing pain and difficulty moving since there is no longer enough cushioning material between the bones.
  • Birth deformity: You may have been born with knee structure that makes the joint vulnerable to slipping out of place.

8 Possible Knee Instability Conditions

The list below shows results from the use of our quiz by Buoy users who experienced knee instability. This list does not constitute medical advice and may not accurately represent what you have.

Meniscal injury

The menisci are the two pieces of cartilage serving as shock absorbers in the knee, between the lower end of the thighbone and the top of the shinbone. A torn meniscus is commonly referred to as "torn cartilage" in the knee.

Damage to a meniscus often happens along with another injury to the knee, especially when there is any forceful, twisting movement or a direct hit such as a tackle.

Older people may tear a meniscus through normal activity if the cartilage has become thin and worn due to aging.

Symptoms include pain, stiffness, and swelling. The knee will simply not work correctly and may catch, lock up, or give way.

Diagnosis is made through patient history, physical examination, simple motion tests, and imaging such as x-ray or MRI.

Depending on the exact form of the injury, the tear may be allowed to heal on its own with supportive care such as rest, ice, and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory pain medication. In other cases, arthroscopic surgery followed by rehabilitation may be needed.

Rarity: Common

Top Symptoms: pain in one knee, knee stiffness, knee instability, pain in the inside of the knee, swollen knee

Urgency: Primary care doctor

Acl injury

The ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) is a super-important tendon that connects the femur (thigh bone) to the tibia (shin), keeping the tibia from flying forward every time a step is taken. Tearing happens in a lot of accidents and sports, unfortunately.

Rarity: Rare

Top Symptoms: knee pain, pain in one knee, knee instability, swollen knee, knee pain from an injury

Symptoms that always occur with acl injury: knee pain

Symptoms that never occur with acl injury: mild knee pain

Urgency: Hospital emergency room

Knee (mcl) sprain

The medical collateral ligament (MCL) links the thigh bone and the shin bone on the inner side of the knee joint. An MCL sprain is any damage done to this ligament (usually through twisting/force during sports).

Rarity: Uncommon

Top Symptoms: pain in one knee, knee pain from an injury, knee injury, pain in the inside of the knee, sports injury

Symptoms that always occur with knee (mcl) sprain: pain in one knee, knee pain from an injury

Symptoms that never occur with knee (mcl) sprain: mild knee pain

Urgency: Primary care doctor

Patellofemoral pain syndrome

Patellofemoral pain syndrome (PFPS) is also called runner's knee, jumper's knee, anterior knee pain, chondromalacia patella, and patellofemoral joint syndrome.

Overuse through training for sports is a common cause, especially if there is a misalignment in the knee joint or a previous knee injury. This wears away the cartilage beneath the kneecap and causes pain on exercising.

It is most common in females and in young adults who are active in sports, but can affect anyone.

Symptoms include dull pain at the front of the knee and around the kneecap (patella) while running, squatting, or climbing stairs, or after prolonged sitting with knees bent.

Diagnosis is made through physical examination and through x-rays, CT scan, and/or MRI.

Treatment most often involves rest; over-the-counter pain relievers; low-impact exercise such as swimming or bicycling; physical therapy to strengthen and stabilize the knee; and orthotics (shoe inserts) to help correct a misaligned stride.

Surgery is needed only for severe cases, and is done through arthroscopy to remove any fragments of damaged cartilage.

Rarity: Common

Top Symptoms: knee pain, pain in one knee, knee pain that gets worse when going up stairs, dull, achy knee pain, knee pain that gets worse when squatting

Symptoms that always occur with patellofemoral pain syndrome: knee pain

Urgency: Primary care doctor

Knee Instability Symptom Checker

Take a quiz to find out what might be causing your knee instability

Repeated kneecap dislocation (patellar subluxation)

Recurrent patellar subluxation is the continued instability of the kneecap, which causes anterior knee pain and usually occurs laterally. It occurs unpredictably with varying durations.

Rarity: Uncommon

Top Symptoms: pain in one knee, dull, achy knee pain, pain in the front of the knee, pain in the inside of the knee, swollen knee

Symptoms that always occur with repeated kneecap dislocation (patellar subluxation): kneecap dislocation

Urgency: Primary care doctor

Knee arthritis

Arthritis is inflammation of one or more of the joints. Pain, swelling, and stiffness are the primary symptoms of arthritis. Any joint in the body may be affected by the disease, but it is particularly common in the knee.

Rarity: Common

Top Symptoms: pain in both knees, knee stiffness, knee instability, swollen knee, morning joint stiffness

Symptoms that always occur with knee arthritis: pain in both knees

Urgency: Primary care doctor

Knee sprain (lcl)

The LCL is the ligament on the outside of the knee, keeping it from bending away from the body. It is most commonly injured while playing sports (ouch!) when a force is placed on the knee from the inner half of the knee.

Rarity: Rare

Top Symptoms: pain in one knee, knee pain from an injury, knee injury, pain in the outside of the knee, sports injury

Symptoms that always occur with knee sprain (lcl): pain in one knee, knee pain from an injury

Symptoms that never occur with knee sprain (lcl): mild knee pain

Urgency: Hospital emergency room

Dislocated kneecap

A dislocated kneecap is when the bone that covers the knee joint, the kneecap or patella, is moved out of place. The kneecap is normally held in place by tendons that connect it to muscles around the knee joint. Dislocation can be caused by planting the foot and twisting a flexed kn...

Read more

Knee Instability Treatments and Relief

At-home treatments

Knee instability remedies that you can try at home include:

  • Rest: Do not try to continue playing or exercising if you have sudden pain in and around the knee.
  • Over-the-counter NSAIDs: You can use ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin) to treat minor pain.

When to see a doctor

You should see your physician if your knee instability is interfering with your life. He or she can help you with the following.

  • Physical therapy: This can provide you with a program of proper stretching and exercise to help strengthen the ligaments, muscles, and tendons of the knee.
  • Possible fitting of braces and supports
  • Surgery to repair damaged cartilage and ligaments

When it is an emergency

You should seek immediate treatment in the emergency room or call 911 if you have severe and sudden pain following an injury, especially if you are unable to move the knee or bear weight on it.

Share your story with others

Once your story is reviewed and approved by our editors, it will live on Buoy as a helpful resource for anyone who may be dealing with something similar.

Questions Your Doctor May Ask About Knee Instability

To diagnose this condition, your doctor would likely ask the following questions:

  • What is your body mass?
  • Do you often feel your knees buckling?
  • Did you feel a pop in your knee?
  • Do you feel like your knee is locking from time to time?

If you've answered yes to one or more of these questions

Please take a quiz to find out what might be causing your knee instability. These questions are also covered.

Take quiz

Knee Instability Symptom Checker Statistics

People who have experienced knee instability have also experienced:

  • 24% Knee Pain
  • 8% Knee That Clicks During Movement
  • 7% Moderate Knee Pain

People who have experienced knee instability were most often matched with:

  • 42% Acl Injury
  • 28% Meniscal Injury
  • 28% Knee (Mcl) Sprain

Source: Aggregated and anonymized results from Buoy Assistant (a.k.a. the quiz).

Knee Instability Symptom Checker

Take a quiz to find out what might be causing your knee instability

No ads, doctor reviewed. Let's crack your symptom code together - like us on Facebook to follow along.